Privacy and Security
Completed Access to Information Requests
Proactive Disclosure
Canadian Radio-Television and Telecommunications CommissionAccess to News Sources
July 2007 Decima Research
Proprietary Warning Table of ContentsExecutive Summary Background, Objectives and Methodology Overall Results
Appendix A: Final Questionnaires Executive SummaryBackground and Objectives:The CRTC was interested in conducting a study with the Canadian general population to help them understand how Canadians obtain their news and how satisfied they are with the various options available to them. More specifically, the primary objectives of this research project were to:
Methodology:
Sources of Local, National and International NewsAn important objective of the research is to determine how Canadians generally obtain local, national and international news. Survey participants were asked to estimate the proportion of news they obtain from television, newspapers, radio and the Internet. Television is the most common source of news, as close to half of respondents obtain their local, national, or international news through this medium. The use of newspapers and radio is more common for accessing local news, while the Internet is more commonly used to access national and international news. Satisfaction with News Sources
Specific Internet Sources Accessed
Internet Versus Traditional Media Sources
Change in Media Usage Behaviour
Usage, adoption and acceptance of new media technologies specific to online video
Background & ObjectivesBackground:The CRTC was interested in conducting a study with those in the Canadian general population to help them understand how Canadians obtain their news and how satisfied they are with the various options available to them. Objectives:The primary objectives of this research project were to:
Methodology
Methodology (Statistical Precision)
Sources for News
A1. Canadians generally obtain their local, national and international news from a variety of sources, including television, radio, newspapers, and the Internet. Thinking of a typical week, approximately what percentage of your news information comes from these various sources? Base: All respondents (n=1,006) Canadians were asked to estimate the percentage of news they obtain from a variety of sources, including television, newspapers, radio and Internet, the latter of which considers news websites, podcasts, blogs, RSS feeds and emails. For local news, more than two-fifths is obtained through television, and about one-quarter is obtained through newspapers. Canadians receive about one-fifth of their local news by listening to the radio, and 9% is accessed through the Internet. Only 1% of news is obtained through other sources. For both national and international news, the distributions are similar. Canadians are much more likely to obtain these types of news by watching television (53% and 55% respectively, vs. 44% for local news). While the percentage of national and international news obtained through newspapers and radio is slightly less than for local news, there is a slightly higher percentage obtained through the Internet
Sources for News By RegionLocal News
National News
International News
A1. Canadians generally obtain their local, national and international news from a variety of sources, including television, radio, newspapers, and the Internet. Thinking of a typical week, approximately what percentage of your news information comes from these various sources? Base: All respondents (n=1,006) Satisfaction with Sources for News
A2. How satisfied are you with each source of information for your news? Please use a scale of 1 to 10, where 1 means "very dissatisfied" and 10 means "very satisfied". Base: Users of media as news sources: TV users (n=906), Radio users (n=659), Newspapers users (n=699), Internet users (n=353). Canadians appear to be mostly satisfied with the Internet (58%) and TV (57%) as a source to obtain local, national or international news (i.e. among those who use the specified news source). Users of radio as a source for news are the least satisfied with this communication channel (39%) compared to satisfaction among users of other types of channels. It is important to note that, from one-third (35%) to half (50%) of media users feel neutral about the specific media they use to obtain news. That being said, less than one-tenth of respondents appear to be dissatisfied with the media source they use as a channel to broadcast news. This low level of dissatisfaction should be expected since this analysis was limited to "users" of each media source. Conceivably someone very dissatisfied with a specific source won't use that given source and would be excluded from the satisfaction analysis for that specific media source.
Television Users
Radio Users
Internet Users
Television
Newspapers
Radio
Internet
A2. How satisfied are you with each source of information for your news? Please use a scale of 1 to 10, where 1 means "very dissatisfied" and 10 means "very satisfied". Base: Users of media as news sources: TV users (n=906), Radio users (n=659), Newspapers users (n=699), Internet users (n=353). Internet as a Source of NewsInternet News Sources
A3a. You said earlier that you obtain at least some of your news from the Internet. Can you please indicate if you use any of the following to access your NEWS from the Internet? Base: Respondents who access at least one type of news via the Internet (n=363). Canadians who access at least one type of news via the Internet were asked to indicate if their Internet sources included emails from websites, blogs, podcasts, or RSS feeds. Approximately four-in-ten do not use any of these sources. The remaining do use emails sent to them directly from a website (43%), blogs (22%), podcasts (12%), or RSS feeds (11%). A few differences across segments are worth noting:
Websites Visited Most Often to Obtain Local NewsLocal News
A3b. Can you please indicate which websites you use most often to obtain each type of news? Base: Respondents who access local news from the Internet (n=278) Online sources of information for local news are highly varied. At the highest end, we see that CBC.ca is used by 14% of Internet users, followed by msn.com/ Sympatico.msn.ca (12%). Search engine news sites are also popular (Google and Yahoo) as are newspaper sites (Globe and Mail and The Star). The use of certain websites varies from region to region. For example, those living in Atlantic Canada (33%), Manitoba or Saskatchewan (22%), and Alberta or British Columbia (21%), are the most likely to visit CBC.ca for local news when compared to Quebec residents. Quebecers are more likely to use either the French counterpart of CBC.ca - that is, Radio-Canada.ca (24%), or Canoe.ca (27%). Common websites for Ontario residents include the Globe and Mail website (12%), and Yahoo News (10%). Yahoo News (news.yahoo.ca) is also popular among Manitoba/ Saskatchewan residents (14%). Those with a household income of at least $40K are more likely to visit CBC.ca compared to those in a lower income bracket (17% vs. 4%). Websites Visited Most Often to Obtain National NewsNational News
A3b. Can you please indicate which websites you use most often to obtain each type of news? The most common online source of information for national news is CBC.ca - over one-quarter of Canadians (27%) use this source. In addition, 5% say they use Radio-Canada.ca for national news. The next most popular sources for national news are msn.com/Sympatico.msn.ca (17%), and CTV.ca (14%). Around one-tenth visit globeandmail.com (11%), news.yahoo.ca (11%), CNN.com (8%), news.google.ca (7%), and Canoe.ca (7%). Residents of Quebec are the least likely to visit CBC.ca, when compared to residents of other parts of Canada. As found with local news, Quebecers are more likely to use Canoe.ca (20%) and Radio-Canada.ca (18%) to access national news. Additionally, Quebecers visit Cyberpresse.ca (14%). Popular sources for national news among residents of Ontario include globeandmail.com (18%), and CNN.com (11%). When looking at gender differences, men appear to be more likely than women to visit news.google.ca (11% vs. 4%), and Canoe.ca (11% vs. 3%). Those with a household income between $40K and $80K are more likely than those in higher income brackets to visit Yahoo's website for national news (18% vs. 2%). The latter, on the other hand, are more likely to visit Canoe.ca (16% vs. 2%). Websites Visited Most Often to Obtain International NewsInternational News
Note: Websites visited by less than 5% of respondents are not shown in this graph.
A3b. Can you please indicate which websites you use most often to obtain each type of news? One quarter of Canadians who access international news online visit CBC.ca (21%) or Radio-Canada.ca (4%). CBC.ca's international news seekers virtually exclude Quebecers and Francophone respondents as they will likely use Canoe.ca (16%) or Radio-Canada.ca (15%). Ontario residents are more likely than other Canadians to visit BBC.com (20%), Yahoo's website (12%), and the Globe and Mail's website (11%). For international news, BBC.com is more likely to be visited by Canadians with a household income under $40K than those with an income of over $80K (32% vs. 10%). Internet as a News Source
A4. Thinking about the Internet as a source of news, do you consider the Internet to be a replacement to traditional media sources such as television, radio and newspapers, or as something complementary to these media sources? Base: All respondents (n=1,006) The evolution of the Internet as a source for news does appear to be having a mild effect on eroding usage of traditional media. Although most Canadians believe that the Internet is a complementary source of information (70%), about one in ten consider it a replacement of traditional media sources. The opinion that the Internet is complementary to traditional media sources is stronger among Canadians under 50 years of age when compared to their elders (76% vs. 63%). This doesn't mean that older Canadians are more likely to consider the Internet a replacement however. In fact, older Canadians are more likely to be uncertain about the Internet's role as a media source (31% among those 50+), compared to those aged 35 to 49 (15%) and those under 34 (8%). In fact, the youngest of these three groups is more likely than those over 50 years of age to say the Internet is replacing traditional media sources (16% vs. 7%).
A4. Thinking about the Internet as a source of news, do you consider the Internet to be a replacement to traditional media sources such as television, radio and newspapers, or as something complementary to these media sources? Base: All respondents (n=1,006) Change in Media Usage Behaviour
A5a. Over the past year, would you say that your use of <MEDIA SOURCE> as a source for news has increased, decreased or stayed the same? While close to two-in-three traditional media users (i.e. of TV, radio and newspapers) believe their use of such media as a news source has remained the same over the past year (62% to 63%), one-fifth believe their use has actually decreased. These results are significantly higher when compared to the opinions of Internet users (35% stayed the same, 6% decreased). On the other hand, close to three-in-five users of the Internet as a source for news say their use of such a medium has increased over the past year (58%). This figure is significantly higher than the increase of TV (16%), radio (16%) or newspaper (17%) usage. Change in Media Usage Behaviour - Demographic DifferencesPerceived changes in media usage over the past year are very consistent across the country. Of note, users of radio in the province of Quebec are more likely than those in other provinces to say their use of radio as a source for news has decreased over the past year.
A5a. Over the past year, would you say that your use of <MEDIA SOURCE> as a source for news has increased, decreased or stayed the same? With Internet Access
Without Internet Access
A5a. Over the past year, would you say that your use of <MEDIA SOURCE> as a source for news has increased, decreased or stayed the same? Canadians with Internet access are more likely than those without Internet access to say their use of the following sources has decreased over the past year:
In fact, those without Internet access are more likely than those without Internet to believe their usage of television has increased over the past year (24% vs. 14%). Reasons for Using the Internet More Often as a News Source
A5b. What has caused the increase of your use of the Internet as a way to access news over the past year? Two-in-five of those who have used the Internet "more often" in the past year cited ease of accessibility as the main reason for an increase in the use of the Internet. Other reasons for using the Internet more often are convenience (15%), access to multiple sources and points of view (11%), being able to select the readings (11%), dissatisfaction with other media (8%), being able to use the Internet while doing other online activities (8%), having a new connection to the Internet or higher speed (8%), having access to up-to-date news (6%), and being able to access the Internet quickly (5%). The Internet's ease of accessibility is more likely to be mentioned by those aged under 49 (43%), compared to those 50 and over (25%). Similarly, younger Canadians are likely to cite being able to use the Internet while doing other online activities, or having Internet access/high speed as their reasons for using the Internet more frequently (10%), compared to older respondents (2% and 1% respectively). Residents of Atlantic Canada (27%), Manitoba and Saskatchewan (26%) are more likely to have increased their use of the Internet due to its convenience as compared to Quebecers (6%). The latter, predominantly Francophones, have a greater tendency to indicate that the Internet allows them to read only what they want (25%), or that they find the Internet quick to access (15%). In addition, those more likely to be dissatisfied with other media are more likely to be women (13% vs. 3% of men) and those with an income under $40K (20% vs. 1% of those with an income of $80K+). Future Change in Media Usage Behaviour
A6. Over the year to come, would you say that your use of <MEDIA SOURCE> as a source for news will increase, stay the same, or decrease? Base: All Respondents (n=1,006) Canadians were also asked to estimate how their usage of the various media sources will evolve over the year to come. Results show that television will continue to be the most popular source for news, with only 8% claiming they will not use that particular medium to access news. As for intentions regarding radio and newspapers, although fully one quarter of Canadians will not use either one of these as sources for news, the proportion claiming to either increase or decrease their usage is consistent with television - in all three cases, roughly one in ten will either increase or decrease their usage of each source. Internet is the one source that is truly different in many respects. One third believe their use of the Internet as a news source will increase, with two-fifths estimating they will not be using the Internet. Only 4% believe their usage of the Internet will decrease. It is important to note here that all households are included in this result, including those without Internet access. Differences among demographic groups in their estimated usage of media for the upcoming year are: Television Usage as a Source of News
Radio Usage as a Source of News
A6. Over the year to come, would you say that your use of <MEDIA SOURCE> as a source for news will increase, stay the same, or decrease? Base: All respondents (n=1,006) Newspapers Usage as a Source for News
Internet Usage as a Source for News
A6. Over the year to come, would you say that your use of <MEDIA SOURCE> as a source for news will increase, stay the same, or decrease? Base: All respondents (n=1,006) Future Change in Media Usage Behaviour - by Province
A6. Over the year to come, would you say that your use of <MEDIA SOURCE> as a source for news will increase, stay the same, or decrease? Base: All respondents (n=1,006) Future Change in Media Usage Behaviour - by Age18-34 (n=167)
35-49 (n=272)
50+ (n=517)
A6. Over the year to come, would you say that your use of <MEDIA SOURCE> as a source for news will increase, stay the same, or decrease? Base: All respondents (n=1,006) Future Change in Media Usage Behaviour - by Internet AccessWith Internet Access (n=773)
Without Internet Access (n=227)
A6. Over the year to come, would you say that your use of <MEDIA SOURCE> as a source for news will increase, stay the same, or decrease? Base: All respondents (n=1,006) New Media: Video OnlineFrequency of Viewing or Downloading Online Video
B1. Approximately how often do you view or download any type of online video? Would you say.? Base: Respondents who have access to the Internet (n=773). Canadians with Internet access were asked how frequently they downloaded online videos. While half of these Canadians (49%) say they never download videos, over one-fifth (23%) download videos at least once a week, 13% do so a few times per month, and 14% less often. Those more likely to download videos at least a few times per week are Internet users:
Among those most likely to never download online videos are residents of rural areas (64%), women (56%), and those at least 35 years of age (61%). Share of Online Video
B2. Approximately what percentage of all the video you watch is over the Internet or from online sources, as opposed to other more traditional media sources such as television, video cassettes and DVD's? Base: Respondents who download online video (n=331). Generally, online video viewing represents a small proportion of all video viewing. For two-in-three Canadians (63%) who download video from the Internet, no more than 25% of the video they watch is over the Internet when considering other more traditional sources such as television, video cassettes and DVD's. About 10% believe their online video viewing represents over 75% of all their video viewing. Canadians under 35 years of age are more likely than those over 50 to say at least three-quarters of their video viewing time is online (13% vs. 4%). Additionally, Canadians with an income between $40K and $80K are more likely than those with higher incomes to say at least three-quarters of their video is watched online (18% vs. 4%). Websites Accessed to View or Download Video
B3. Which websites do you access most often to view or download video content? By far, the most popular website to view or download video is Youtube.com (37%). Other notable mentions among online video viewers include msn.com (9%), CBC.ca (7%), CNN.com (7%), Limewire.com (5%), CTV.ca (5%), BBC.com (4%), Yahoo News (4%), Google News (4%), iTunes (3%), and Google.com (3%). Those more likely to use Youtube.com include those aged between 18 and 34 (50%), and between 35 and 49 (30%), compared to those over 50 (16%). CBC.ca is popular for video watching among residents of Manitoba and Saskatchewan (17%), and Alberta and British Columbia (13%). CNN.com is more likely to be used by residents of Ontario (9%). Satisfaction with Online Video
B4. On a scale of 1 to 10, where 1 means "very dissatisfied" and 10 means "very satisfied", generally how satisfied are you with the overall image/picture quality of video online - that is, when compared to traditional TV and DVD quality? Base: Respondents who download online video (n=331). One-third (34%) of those who download video from the Internet are satisfied with the overall image and picture quality of online video when compared to traditional TV and DVD quality. Approximately half of these Canadians are neutral about the image quality of online video, when compared to other digital or traditional video (i.e. DVD, TV), while 8% are dissatisfied with the image quality. Residents of Quebec (10%), Ontario (9%), and Manitoba or Saskatchewan (17%), are more likely to be dissatisfied with the image quality of online video, compared to residents of Atlantic Canada (1%). Change in Use of Traditional Sources of Video
B5. How has your use of traditional sources of video such as television, DVD's and video cassettes changed since you've started viewing or downloading video on the Internet? Would you say it has. Base: Respondents who download online video (n=331). Over 7-in-10 Canadians who download video say their use of traditional sources of video (TV, DVD, VHS, etc.) has remained the same, despite their use of online video (71%). Another 16% believe their use has decreased, while 12% say it has increased. Those aged 18 to 34 are more likely to say their traditional video viewing has decreased since they started using online video (22%), while men (15%) and those over 35 years of age (17%) are more likely to say their use of traditional video has increased. Online Video as a Viewing Source
B6. Would you consider viewing video online to be a replacement to traditional sources of viewing, or that it is complementary to existing sources of viewing? Base: Respondents who download online video (n=331). The majority of those who download online video consider their use of online video as complementary to traditional sources of viewing. About one-in-ten consider online video to be a replacement of traditional media sources. Men (16%) and Canadians under 35 years of age (18%) are more likely to consider online video a replacement. Change in Online Video Usage
B7. Over the year to come, do you expect the amount of online video you will access or download will.? Five times as many Canadians expect their use of online video to increase than decrease. One-quarter of Canadians estimate that their usage of online video for the upcoming year will increase (25%), while 62% think it will stay the same and 5% believe it will decrease. Canadians more likely to estimate an increase in their online video usage include residents of Ontario (27%), Manitoba or Saskatchewan (34%), Alberta or British Columbia (30%), Anglophones (28%), and those aged 18 to 34 (31%) or 35 to 49 (27%). On the other hand, those more likely to estimate a decrease in their online video usage are residents of Quebec (10%), and Francophone respondents (11%). Those who tend to be the most indecisive about their future online video usage include residents of Quebec (20%), Francophones (20%), women (11%), and those over 35 years of age (10%). Users of Online Video
Non-users of Online Video
B7. Over the year to come, do you expect the amount of online video you will access or download will.? By considering future online video usage intentions based on whether or not the respondent currently accessed this type of content, we can see some interesting trends developing. Predictably, future growth in usage is in large part driven by current users. This should not however overshadow the fact that an important proportion (15%) of "non-users" expect the amount of online video they access to increase over the year to come. Among existing users, provinces west of Quebec seem to be leading the charge, with increase rates of at least 40%. We are also seeing that the results for Quebec are being distorted by non-users. A very important proportion of non-users did not know how their future use of online video will evolve (39%). We could speculate that the concept of online video downloading or streaming may not have been clearly understood by this segment in Quebec.
Appendix A
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||