
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS BEFORE
THE CANADIAN RADIO‑TELEVISION AND
TELECOMMUNICATIONS
COMMISSION
TRANSCRIPTION
DES AUDIENCES DEVANT
LE
CONSEIL DE LA RADIODIFFUSION
ET
DES TÉLÉCOMMUNICATIONS CANADIENNES
SUBJECT
/ SUJET:
Various broadcasting applications /
Diverses demandes de radiodiffusion
HELD AT: TENUE À:
Quartz Ballroom Quartz Ballroom
Matrix Hotel Matrix Hôtel
10001-107th Street 10001-107th Street
Edmonton, Alberta Edmonton (Alberta)
May 27, 2008 Le 27 mai 2008
Transcripts
In order to meet the requirements of the Official Languages
Act, transcripts of proceedings before the Commission will be
bilingual as to their covers, the listing of the CRTC members
and staff attending the public hearings, and the Table of
Contents.
However, the aforementioned publication is the recorded
verbatim transcript and, as such, is taped and transcribed in
either of the official languages, depending on the language
spoken by the participant at the public hearing.
Transcription
Afin de rencontrer les exigences de la Loi sur
les langues
officielles, les procès‑verbaux pour le
Conseil seront
bilingues en ce qui a trait à la page
couverture, la liste des
membres et du personnel du CRTC participant à
l'audience
publique ainsi que la table des matières.
Toutefois, la publication susmentionnée est un
compte rendu
textuel des délibérations et, en tant que tel,
est enregistrée
et transcrite dans l'une ou l'autre des deux
langues
officielles, compte tenu de la langue utilisée
par le
participant à l'audience publique.
Canadian
Radio‑television and
Telecommunications
Commission
Conseil
de la radiodiffusion et des
télécommunications canadiennes
Transcript / Transcription
Various broadcasting applications /
Diverses demandes de radiodiffusion
BEFORE / DEVANT:
Elizabeth Duncan Chairperson / Présidente
Rita Cugini Commissioner
/ Conseillère
Candice Molnar Commissioner
/ Conseillère
Peter Menzies Commissioner
/ Conseiller
Marc Patrone Commissioner
/ Conseiller
ALSO PRESENT / AUSSI PRÉSENTS:
Cindy Ventura Secretary / Sécretaire
Lyne Cape Hearing Manager /
Gérante de l'audience
Regan Morris Legal
Counsel
Conseiller
Juridique
HELD AT: TENUE À:
Quartz Ballroom Quartz Ballroom
Matrix Hotel Matrix Hôtel
10001-107th Street 10001-107th Street
Edmonton, Alberta Edmonton (Alberta)
May 27, 2008 Le 27 mai 2008
- iv -
TABLE
DES MATIÈRES / TABLE OF CONTENTS
PAGE / PARA
PHASE I
PRESENTATION BY / PRÉSENTATION PAR:
Newcap Inc. 4 / 23
Thomas Bolin (OBCI) 94 / 586
Golden West Broadcasting Ltd. 153 / 1045
PHASE II
INTERVENTION BY / INTERVENTION PAR:
Thomas Bolin (OBCI) 223 / 1534
PHASE III
No interventions / Aucune intervention
PHASE IV
REPLY BY / RÉPLIQUE PAR:
Newcap Inc. 227 / 1568
Edmonton,
Alberta / Edmonton (Alberta)
‑‑‑ Upon
commencing on Tuesday, May 27, 2008 at 0930 /
L'audience
débute le mardi 27 mai 2008 à 0930
1 THE
CHAIRPERSON: Good morning, ladies and
gentlemen, and welcome to this public hearing.
My name is Elizabeth Duncan. I am
the CRTC Commissioner for the Atlantic Region, and I will be presiding over
this hearing.
2 Joining me on the
panel are my colleagues Rita Cugini, Regional Commissioner for Ontario; Candice
Molnar, Regional Commissioner for Manitoba and Saskatchewan; Peter Menzies,
Commissioner; and Marc Patrone, Commissioner.
3 The Commission
team assisting us includes the Hearing Manager, Lyne Cape, who is also Manager
of Radio Operations and Policy; Regan Morris, Legal Counsel; and Cindy Ventura,
Hearing Secretary.
4 Please speak with
Ms Ventura if you have any questions with regard to the procedures.
5 This hearing will
be conducted in two parts. We will start
by considering the radio applications for the Drumheller and Red Deer markets
this week. We will then examine the
radio applications for the Edmonton market during the week of June 2nd.
6 At the hearing,
beginning today, the panel will look at three applications to operate a new
English‑language FM commercial radio station in Drumheller.
7 Following this,
the panel will study eight applications to operate a new English‑language
FM commercial radio station in Red Deer.
8 We will also
consider an application to change the authorized contours of Radio Station CJUV‑FM
Lacombe, and to relocate its transmitter to Red Deer.
9 I will now invite
the Hearing Secretary, Cindy Ventura, to explain the procedures that we will be
following.
10 THE
SECRETARY: Thank you, Madam Chair.
11 Before beginning,
I would like to go over a few housekeeping matters to ensure the proper conduct
of the hearing.
12 Le service
d'interprétation simultanée est disponible durant cette audience. Vous pouvez vous procurer un récepteur auprès
du technicien à l'arrière de la salle.
L'interprétation anglaise se trouve au canal 1 et l'interprétation
française au canal 2.
13 When you are in
the Hearing Room, we would ask that you please turn off your cell phones,
beepers and BlackBerrys, as they are an unwelcome distraction and they cause
interference on the internal communications system used by our
translators. We would appreciate your
cooperation in this regard throughout the hearing.
14 We expect the
entire hearing to take approximately nine days, starting today, until next
Friday. We will begin each morning this
week at 9:30 a.m. We will take an hour
for lunch, a break in the morning and in the afternoon. We will let you know of any schedule changes
as they may occur.
15 The Amber B Room
will serve as the Examination Room, where you can examine the public files of
the applications being considered at this hearing.
16 As indicated in
the agenda, the telephone number of the Examination Room is 780‑429‑7498.
17 There is a
verbatim transcript of this hearing being taken by the court reporter sitting
at the table in front of me. If you have
any questions on how to obtain all or part of this transcript, please approach
the court reporter during a break.
18 Please note that
the full transcript will be made available on the Commission's website shortly
after the conclusion of the hearing.
19 Now, Madam Chair,
we will proceed with Item 1 on the agenda, which is an application by Newcap
Inc. for a licence to operate an English‑language FM commercial radio
programming undertaking in Drumheller.
20 The new station
would operate on Frequency 102.7 MHz, with an effective radiated power of 6,000
watts, non‑directional antenna, antenna height of 80.6 metres.
21 Appearing for the
Applicant is Mr. Rob Steele.
22 Please introduce
your colleagues. You will have 20
minutes to make your presentation.
*PRESENTATION / PRÉSENTATION
23 MR. STEELE: Thank you.
24 Good morning,
Madam Chair and Commission Staff. I am
Rob Steele, President and Chief Executive Officer of Newcap Radio.
25 Before we begin
our presentation, I would like to introduce our team.
26 Seated in the
front row, farthest to my left, is Glenda Spenrath, Newcap's Director of
Operations.
27 Next to Glenda is
Ron Thompson, the General Manager of our Southern Alberta Radio Group,
including our station in Drumheller. Ron
has over 45 years in radio, with the last 27 years in Alberta radio.
28 Next to Ron is
Brent Young. Brent is the Program
Director for our existing Drumheller service, CKDQ‑AM. He is a native Albertan, with over 20 years
dedicated to the radio broadcast industry.
29 Brent also
oversees the programming activity of our Alberta south group of stations.
30 Beside Brent is
Sue Stevenson, News Director of CKDQ‑AM, as well as KG Country and Z99 in
Red Deer.
31 Sue has almost 30
years of news experience in radio, with more than 20 of them in our newsroom in
southern Alberta.
32 Beside Sue is
Steve Jones, Vice‑President of Programming for Newcap.
33 And next to Steve
is David Murray, Chief Operating Officer.
34 I would also like
to note the presence in the audience of Rick Walters, our newly hired General
Manager for our Drumheller country AM station, CKDQ. Rick is literally on his way to Drumheller to
start his new duties later this week. He
has a long background in radio programming and management, and if we are
successful in this application, Rick will also be the General Manager of the
new FM station.
35 We are here today
to present our application to provide an additional programming option in
Drumheller, a high‑quality alternative choice that will be viable because
of its connection to the existing station in the market.
36 I would now like
to call upon Ron Thompson to begin our presentation.
37 MR. THOMPSON: Thanks, Rob, and good morning, Commissioners.
38 Drumheller is a
small town in the Dinosaur Valley in the Alberta Badlands. The population of the town is 7,800 people,
and the economy is based upon three pillars:
agriculture, tourism, and oil and gas production.
39 The trading area
of the town includes about 30,000 people, many of whom look to Drumheller for
their shopping and other services. But
despite this extended market, the limitations of the frequencies available mean
that none of the applicants can reach more than the population of the town
itself.
40 All of the
applications before you for this market are for small signals that,
effectively, only reach the town and its immediate area.
41 The 3 millivolt
contour of our proposed station would reach only 8,500 people, and, in fact,
the other two applicants would reach fewer than 8,000 with their 3 millivolt
contours.
42 Currently we
provide a full‑service AM country music station in Drumheller, CKDQ‑AM,
known as Q91. With 50,000 watts and a
clear signal, we are able to provide coverage to a much larger market, from the
Rockies in the west to the Saskatchewan border in the east, and from Ponoka in
the north to Brooks in the south.
43 We are the only
radio station serving many of the smaller communities within our service
area. They include communities such as
Hannah, Oyen, Rumsey, Bassano, Strathmore, Carbon, Veteran, and Coronation, to
mention a few.
44 Madam Chair, we
are able to sustain the rich service that our AM station provides to Drumheller
for a number of reasons. With our reach
to the many small towns in rural areas, we actually have a market of about 30,000
people. In fact, the Town of Drumheller
represents less than 20 percent of our total revenues.
45 Q91 is part of our
Alberta Radio Group. The ARG allows us
to share costs such as copy, traffic, engineering and other services, while at
the same time enriching the programming services.
46 Being part of the
ARG brings radio revenues to Q91 that it would not get as a stand‑alone
local broadcaster. Our coverage of
southern Alberta allows us access to regional revenues from sources such as
farm implement dealers and multi‑outlet retailers that would normally not
buy a small radio station.
47 We are also able
to aggregate audiences to make our group more attractive to national buyers.
48 And now, to tell
you how we choose our music format, here is Steve Jones.
49 MR. JONES: Thanks, Ron, and good morning.
50 While the country
music format is very popular, especially here in Alberta, it remains a very
polarizing format. Those who like it,
like it a lot, and devote long hours tuned to it.
51 In a small
community like Drumheller, with only one station, everyone has to listen to the
only station in town to get the local news and other community information, but
they resent it when they are forced to listen to music they don't like to get
the services they need.
52 As is our practice
whenever we look at providing a new service to a market, we undertook consumer
research to determine what Drumheller listeners want in a new radio station.
53 Mark Kasoff and
Company interviewed 150 people between the ages of 25 and 64. Not surprisingly, our local country station,
Q91, has the largest audience of any station.
54 But as we looked
deeper, a number of interesting trends emerged.
55 With only one
local station, those who do not like country music often listen to out‑of‑market
stations. Although the community itself
is located deep in a valley, making reliable reception of out‑of‑market
stations difficult, the Kasoff research indicates that CJFM, 660 News, JACK FM
and QR77, all from the Calgary market, attract substantial tuning in Drumheller.
56 Those who don't
like country music must put up with poor signals, or use the internet or cable
radio to get the music formats they want.
But when they want local news and community information, it is either
our country station, Q91, or nothing at all.
57 Not surprisingly,
as a result, satisfaction with existing radio choices in Drumheller is high
with only one group of listeners, country music fans. After all, these are the listeners who are
well served by the existing station.
58 Men of all ages
are generally less satisfied with the existing radio choices. In fact, among male listeners, Calgary
stations are the most listened to stations.
59 Among women, those
under 45 were the least satisfied. With
25 to 34‑year‑old female listeners, JACK FM from Calgary is the
most listened to station.
60 Clearly, a format
that attracts men across many age groups and women under 45 is the best
choice. So what did the research tell us
was the appropriate format to meet this need?
61 Mr. Kasoff
investigated the viability of nine different types of music: active rock, CHR, classic hits, classic rock,
country, hot AC, soft AC, sixties and seventies oldies, as well as eighties and
nineties pop.
62 It became clear
that one format in particular stood out ‑‑ that format is
classic hits.
63 That conclusion
was based on a calculation called "The Percent of Format Void", which
is essentially a numerical representation of a format's potential for success,
based on the popularity of the type of music and its present availability in
the market. Classic hits had the highest
percent of format void, at 17 percent, followed by classic rock and CHR at 13
percent, and sixties and seventies oldies and eighties and nineties pop, each
with 11 percent.
64 Classic hits,
classic rock, sixties and seventies oldies, and eighties and nineties pop are
often grouped together on radio stations to create broad‑based classic
hits stations.
65 For example, our
recently launched 96.3 Capital FM here in Edmonton brings together elements of
each type of music to create a cohesive and popular format that could
conceivably play everything from 1964's "I Want to Hold Your Hand" by
The Beatles to 1992's "Courage" by The Tragically Hip.
66 The strong
positive interest in all of these types of complementary musical styles led us
to the conclusion that a station like this would be a tremendous success in
Drumheller.
67 Now to give you a
better idea of how this new station will sound, here is Brent Young.
68 MR. YOUNG: Thanks, Steve, and good morning.
69 We have labelled
the station T‑REX 102.7, after the famous dinosaur that once called the
Drumheller area home. It will be a rock‑based
classic hit station, with its music coming from the sixties through the end of
the nineties.
70 Approximately 35
percent of the station's sound will draw from the traditional classic hits
repertoire of the eighties, nineties and now, from artists like Fleetwood Mac,
Elton John, The Guess Who and John Mellencamp.
71 About 25 percent
of the sound will come from classic rock artists like Arrowsmith, Rush and Led
Zeppelin.
72 The spice on the
meat and potatoes of classic hits and classic rock will come from two
sources. About 15 percent of the music
will come from oldies from the sixties and seventies, with artists like The Beatles,
The Beach Boys, Three Dog Night, and The Stampeders, with a further 15 percent
from eighties and nineties artists like Bryan Adams, Huey Lewis and the News,
R.E.M. and Glass Tiger.
73 The remaining 10
percent of our musical sound will come from compatible Canadian contemporary
artists like Sam Roberts, The Trews, Tomi Swick, and Jim Cuddy.
74 At Newcap we have
invested a significant amount of money in helping to create new stars through
initiatives like "The Big Money Shot" in Ottawa and "Big Rock Star"
in Calgary.
75 These result in
strong albums from emerging artists like Ottawa's Sojourn and Loudlove, and
Calgary's The Dudes.
76 We are committed
to giving these artists exposure on all of our rock stations, from St. John's
through the maritimes, Ontario and Alberta.
77 In Drumheller, a
new rock‑based station could provide exposure for these artists. They will be presented on our station as
future classics.
78 While a larger
market with numerous competitive signals may require a classic hits station to
be more singular in focus, a smaller market like Drumheller demands a radio
station with a broader appeal, allowing T‑REX 102.7 to include some newer
music.
79 In addition to an
around‑the‑clock supply of great music, we will provide some
special interest programs, focusing on specific eras, some sub‑genres of
music, and lots of listener interaction.
80 Here is a small
sample of the kinds of music features we will run:
81 "Psychedelic
Sundays" ‑‑ a look at the artists of the sixties and
seventies, with a focus on the new rock sounds that were emerging then, from
The Electric Prunes to Neil Young, and even some folk music that was part of
that era, like Joni Mitchell or Bob Dylan.
We will help the Woodstock‑era audience remember their youth.
82 Every weekday at
noon we will host "The Resurrection Lunch", where we will invite
listeners to resurrect their favourite classic songs, from album tracks to one‑hit
wonders.
83 Friday nights at
eight we will celebrate the beginning of the weekend with the eighties,
featuring the best hair bands of the eighties, like Quiet Riot, Poison,
Toronto's Motley Crue, Triumph, and more.
84 We know from
experience that classic hits, classic rock, and oldies' listeners love the
music of the past, but they live in the here and now, and here to tell us about
our news and spoken word commitment is Sue Stevenson.
85 MS STEVENSON: In Drumheller, our existing station, Q91, has
two full‑time newspeople, Kevin Wyonzek and Bob Brown. Kevin has 17 years of experience in
Drumheller, while Bob has 10. They
provide our regular local newscasts, with a total of over five hours a week,
including in‑depth agricultural news.
86 They cover local
news extensively, and with dedication.
87 For example, in
June of 2005 the Town of Drumheller was faced with a major flood threat. Q91 played a significant role in mobilizing a
community response, and, in fact, broke away from regular weekend programming
and went live for more than 24 hours, until that threat passed.
88 A letter from then
Deputy Premier Shirley McClellan noted that the Q91 coverage led to the
tremendous outpouring of support that the Drumheller Valley experienced during
those tense hours and days.
89 The story was also
an example of our regional news‑sharing capabilities, as the City of Red
Deer also faced a major flood threat and our two newsrooms were able to share
pertinent information with our listeners.
90 Kevin and Bob also
feed their stories to our database in Red Deer, where a package of southern
Alberta news stories is made available to all of our Alberta Newcap stations.
91 Here is a recent
example of how this works.
92 In November, the
RCMP issued an AMBER Alert about a kidnapped boy. Within minutes of receiving that
notification, we were on the air with the news.
93 At the same time,
Q91 fed that story to Red Deer and to our regional and Alberta newsrooms.
94 The story ended
well, when the boy was found unharmed, about half an hour after the story was
broadcast.
95 This regional
connection enables Kevin and Bob to concentrate on live local newscasts
throughout the high audience parts of the day, and to do a full job of news
gathering from our extended coverage area.
96 At the same time,
in off‑peak hours we can provide a southern Alberta newscast from our hub
in Red Deer, with input from all of the various markets we serve there.
97 Listeners receive
a package of news focused on their hometown and their region, rather than a
newscast packaged in Toronto.
98 The addition of T‑REX
in Drumheller will allow us to expand our news operation there. With three new people in the newsroom, we
will ensure live local newscasts for the two stations throughout the day, but
can also get out to our community and the area to a greater extent.
99 These additional
resources will enable us to reach our ambitious plan for local news, which will
include four‑minute newscasts on the hour in morning drive, at noon, and
during afternoon drive, from Monday to Friday, with three minutes of pure news
in each one.
100 On Saturday and
Sunday we will provide newscasts between 6 a.m. and 5 p.m., and shorter two‑and‑a‑half
minute news updates on the half‑hour during morning drive weekdays.
101 In all, there will
be 4 hours and 46 minutes of newscasts each week.
102 While we will
share news gathering between T‑REX and Q91, the newscasts will be
tailored to the different audiences of the two stations.
103 For example, there
will be a stronger emphasis on agriculture and agribusiness on Q91, given its
country format and its extended coverage area, which includes many farms and
ranches.
104 T‑REX will
have a greater emphasis on town events, as well as on lifestyle issues
affecting younger families.
105 Our reflection of
the community will go beyond the news we carry, with a variety of information
and features. Apart from the regular
weather and environmental updates that all listeners want, we will also provide
a number of features, as outlined in our application. These include "Community Action",
"Crime Stoppers", employment information, and "What's On".
106 Q91 is heavily
involved in the local community. For
example, the station recently received a provincial award for a series of
programs aimed at reducing youth smoking, which aired on Q91. The program was a collaboration between Q91,
local school students, and the Alberta Alcohol and Drug Abuse Commission. And we will bring the same involvement to T‑REX.
107 We will be live
and local 10 hours every weekday, with a strong emphasis on the morning and
afternoon drive periods.
108 In order to
provide such service to a small community, we will use voice tracking in other
periods.
109 With the expanded
programming presence in our stations, we will have people in the station, or on
call, at all times to ensure the timely broadcast of emergency information.
110 In all, we will
provide approximately 17 hours of spoken word programming each week.
111 And, now, to
discuss Canadian Content Development, and to sum up, here, once again, is Ron
Thompson.
112 MR. THOMPSON: Thanks, Sue.
113 Newcap will
contribute $70,000 over the course of the seven‑year term of the licence
to CCD initiatives. That is above and
beyond the required basic amount.
Fourteen thousand dollars, or 20 percent, will go to FACTOR, and the
remainder will be directed to initiatives in the Drumheller District School
Board.
114 The $56,000 will
go to purchase musical instruments, provide music scholarships, and fund
participation in music festivals.
115 Madam Chair and
Members of the Commission, Newcap is able to provide a second service in
Drumheller for two reasons: the existing
infrastructure of Q91 allows us to do this economically by sharing facilities
and some functions, and the strong backbone that the ARG provides allows us to
provide back office functions in a very cost‑effective manner.
116 When Newcap
acquired the small market stations throughout Alberta, we developed a plan to
make them viable ‑‑ upgrade the physical plant, including FM
conversions where appropriate; research the needs of the community for
programming services; and put the right people in place to deliver.
117 This has resulted
in a substantial increase of local programming, and the elimination of province‑wide
networking.
118 But we also knew
that, despite the strong Alberta economy, these small markets had limits to
what they could support.
119 We divided the
province into three areas, with hub stations in the largest markets providing
engineering, accounting, copywriting, and traffic, as well as other functions,
while developing experts in various kinds of content, particularly agriculture. This permits us to keep costs where they
should be, in programming. And we have
been very successful at this approach.
120 Drumheller is a
small community, with only one local radio station ‑‑ a very
good country radio station, providing excellent service to the town, in a
relatively large rural area, but the people can hear a variety of music formats
from other markets; not necessarily well, but well enough to know that they
would like additional local musical choice, and, of course, the FM quality.
121 We have the
expertise and the resources in place to meet these needs.
122 Our proposal
represents a significant increase in investment in Drumheller, but we are
confident that we can provide a better service to the community we serve.
123 We are the only
applicant that undertook comprehensive, independent research to identify the
town's preferences, and have crafted a proposal that reflects what we found
out.
124 We hope that you
will give us the opportunity to deliver on our promises, and we would be
pleased to reply to your questions.
125 THE
CHAIRPERSON: Thank you very much.
126 I will lead the
questions. I think you have answered
some of them, at any rate, but maybe some I will ask just for clarification.
127 I was going to
confirm your spoken word commitments, as outlined in your October 31st letter,
but I see that I have a slightly different breakdown, and that the spoken word
programming, the news element of it, actually ties in with your supplementary
brief, the four minutes and 46 seconds.
So we will take the 17 minutes and 7 as the gospel.
128 MR. MURRAY: That's right.
129 THE
CHAIRPERSON: The local news
component ‑‑ what would the local news component be?
130 MS STEVENSON: When you are asking for the local news
component, are you asking for the time or an actual breakdown?
131 THE
CHAIRPERSON: I am actually asking for
the amount of time, the four minutes and 46 seconds, but I would be interested
in a breakdown, as well, if you have one.
132 MS STEVENSON: That would include 79 newscasts per week,
which would include, of course, sports and weather.
133 Are you asking for
actual times or ‑‑
134 THE
CHAIRPERSON: I notice that weather you
had indicated was 39.5 minutes, I think, per week, and weather and sports.
135 MS STEVENSON: That's correct.
136 THE
CHAIRPERSON: So the news was the
difference, which was 3 hours and 18 minutes.
But how much of that is pure local news?
137 MS STEVENSON: We would have 75 percent local news content.
138 THE
CHAIRPERSON: I noticed in your brief, at
page 15, that you refer to "Two extended news bulletins, which will
represent a comprehensive news roundup and allow for considered examination of
major local issues each day."
139 I am wondering
where that appears in the information you have given us.
140 MS STEVENSON: What we would do is, our 8 a.m. and noon
newscasts would be major newscasts. We
would increase elements in there, and some of our "Community Action"
and "Crime Stoppers" features would run in that time slot.
141 We would also
allow time for extended interviews with community leaders, if we wanted to
expand on a topic. That would be going
into the 8 a.m. and noon major newscasts.
142 THE
CHAIRPERSON: When you say extended news
bulletins, that is not included in the four minutes. Those newscasts are over and above.
143 MS STEVENSON: It would be included in the newscast, so we
would possibly have to extend the time of those newscasts, as warranted.
144 It would include
extended interviews, plus a number of other features that would go into those
newscasts.
145 THE
CHAIRPERSON: So this is the minimum, I
guess.
146 MS STEVENSON: That would be the minimum, yes.
147 THE
CHAIRPERSON: Okay. Thank you.
148 The trend amongst
broadcasters operating commercial music‑based formats is to offer considerably
less spoken word programming than you are proposing, and I am wondering if you
could elaborate on why you think your approach is going to be successful, given
that your listeners, the ones that you are projecting to take over from CJAY in
Calgary and JACK in Calgary, are conditioned to a less talk/more music radio
environment.
149 MR. JONES: There are probably a number of factors that
go into answering that question. One of
them is the fact that Drumheller is a small market, and we would be the only FM
service there.
150 When you are in a
larger market and you can turn broadcasting into narrowcasting, you can start
to eliminate different elements of your programming that might not appeal to
that core group of listeners you are after.
151 But in a smaller
market you are required to be a bit more broad, and that would probably account
for a lot of what you see here as far as music format goes, and also as far as
spoken word goes.
152 Also, of those
Calgary stations that we noted are the most listened to, two of them are news
talk stations. There is a hunger for
information in the market, a hunger for information because there is no other
station there to provide it.
153 THE
CHAIRPERSON: Is JACK a news station?
154 MR. JONES: No.
QR77 and 6620 News are news. JACK
and CJAY are music stations.
155 THE
CHAIRPERSON: I think that quite a
substantial portion of your out‑of‑market tuning, or repatriation,
you were expecting to come from JACK.
156 MR. JONES: Yes, and that is more due to the fact that,
musically, JACK is a radio station that plays a gold‑based library, as
would our station.
157 THE
CHAIRPERSON: It is interesting, because
I see from your sheet that you have better defined for me, or set it out more
clearly for me what the broad base is going to encompass.
158 Your listeners,
you expect, will stay tuned and be interested to the variety this gives
them. They are not just interested in
classic rock, for example, they are going to stay and listen to the others.
159 MR. JONES: What we have found in the past in other
markets is that, if you put together format styles that are somewhat
compatible, you can achieve that. So
classic hits and classic rock and elements of sixties/seventies oldies and eighties/nineties
pop can fit together rather cohesively.
160 If you expand that
too far, I think you begin to lose, as opposed to gain.
161 MR. MURRAY: Madam Chair, if I could, I would like to
expand a little bit on the answer to your question about why we are offering so
much news.
162 This is a trend
that you have seen in applications from Newcap, and from a lot of other
broadcasters, quite frankly, because terrestrial radio realizes that it needs
to expand its news. It is the single
most important element in competing with satellite and iPods and internet radio
and other things of this nature.
163 We have taken a
very aggressive approach to this in this application and in other applications,
but also in our existing radio stations.
164 As you can see, we
have 5 hours in CKDQ Drumheller. So it's
not something that we are just promising here at the Commission, it is
something that we believe very strongly in, very deeply in, and it is very
important to our long‑term success.
165 THE
CHAIRPERSON: That is very helpful. Personally, I like a lot of news and
information, so I am glad to hear that that's the way the pendulum is moving.
166 The Commercial
Radio Policy, as you well know, states that local programming includes
programming that originates with the station.
I have a few questions, and I would like to better understand your
Alberta Radio Group. You have quite a
bit of it covered in here, so don't hesitate to repeat the answer. This is just so I make sure that I clearly
understand what is happening.
167 I am wondering how
many hours of station‑produced programming you are proposing a week in
Drumheller.
168 MR. MURRAY: I think I will start off.
169 I am not sure what
the question is.
170 THE
CHAIRPERSON: Let me add this, and maybe
it will help because you can sort of roll probably all the answer into one.
171 I want to
understand how the Alberta Radio Group works.
I had understood from some information that I was given ‑‑
and this was in regards to your Stats Can reports, your statistical
information ‑‑ that it was eliminated, that the Alberta Radio
Network had been eliminated. So I'm
incorrect in that, I gather, from what you said here.
172 MR. MURRAY: Right, yes.
173 THE
CHAIRPERSON: So maybe you could just
explain to me what role it plays in your programming. So how much is actually local and customized
to the community and how much is more regional.
I guess you would consider that regional.
174 MR. MURRAY: Right, okay, fine.
175 The Alberta Radio
Group ‑‑ the Alberta Radio Group exists and it is a number of
stations and, as Ron said in the opening remarks, it's now broken up into three
hubs.
176 The way it used to
operate was an Alberta Radio Network broadcast out of Edmonton. So in Edmonton after morning drive on all of
these dozen or more stations, the same music, the same news, the same
programming for the rest of the day all was exactly the same on all those
stations, which is something we recognize as that's not the appropriate way to
provide service to these small communities and it's not a successful model.
177 So what we have
done we have broken it into three hubs, but every single station produces 100
percent local programming. Some of that
programming might be voice tracked but typically about half of the programming
is live and produced in that market by people on the ground in those markets,
depending on the size of the market.
178 So for example in
this station it's exactly what we are proposing. 66 hours on this new station will be live
produced by people in Drumheller on the new FM and the remaining will be voice
tracked by people either in Drumheller working or in Red Deer which is our
southern hub.
179 So that's how we
have changed the Alberta Radio Group quite dramatically. So it used to be called the Alberta Radio
Network. We took network away.
180 And when you are
talking about the financial aspect of that, yes, there was some confusion with
our financials in Drumheller and that was just sort of an unfortunate ‑‑
it was a mistake. We were asked by
Statistics Canada to look at the annual returns. We used to file the Alberta Radio Network as
a separate station. It had no revenue
and it had all expenses and they said, "We don't want you to do that
anymore. Please add it to your largest
station in the group rather than breaking it down". For whatever reason that's what they wanted.
181 So we added it to
our largest market and then Drumheller became our largest market, and we moved
it to Drumheller. But what we reported
back to the people that we were asking is that in 2008 all of those expenses have
actually been ‑‑ they're gone but, you know, people still
exist but they have been moved into these hubs and they will show up in
different ways. I don't know if that
helps.
182 THE
CHAIRPERSON: All right. So I am probably going to have a few
questions falling out of that then.
183 So what year was
the change with Stats Canada made? Was
that in ‑‑ was it eliminated in '07 or '06?
184 MR. MURRAY: Well, the change to the hubs took place in
'06 and '07 and were calendar years. So
that spanned '05, '06 and '07 for the broadcast calendar. And like, I say now, in '08 there will be
zero costs in what we used to call the Edmonton hub, the single hub. So that will disappear in '08.
185 THE
CHAIRPERSON: Okay. But now there is three hubs as you say and
the hub that Drumheller would be in it falls in the Red River in the ‑‑
186 MR. MURRAY: Red Deer.
187 THE
CHAIRPERSON: Red Deer hub; is that
correct?
188 MR. MURRAY: That's right but there is no allocation of
costs. You know if there is extra costs
in Red Deer they are either in Red Deer or say if there is a person in Red Deer
that most of their work is done for Drumheller, well, then they are charged 100
percent to Drumheller.
189 THE
CHAIRPERSON: Repeat that again.
190 MR. MURRAY: Like say there could be a person who is in
Red Deer because that's the best place for them to be because they get
supervision and mentoring and backup and all these sort of things. But if 80 percent of their work is for the
CKDQ‑AM Drumheller station we just simply charge them to Drumheller.
191 THE
CHAIRPERSON: Okay.
192 MR. MURRAY: We don't try to identify a hub cost and take
5 percent of this and 10 percent of that and 12 percent of this. It's just that's just too confusing.
193 THE
CHAIRPERSON: So those decisions are made
like once a year and the person if you designate them as a Drumheller person is
in there for the charge for the whole year?
194 MR. MURRAY: Correct.
195 THE
CHAIRPERSON: You know, do it by a time
card or that type of thing?
196 MR. MURRAY: That's correct, exactly.
197 THE
CHAIRPERSON: So the voice tracking ‑‑
so did I understand you to say 50 percent would be locally produced? Did you say that?
198 MR. MURRAY: Well, 100 percent would be locally produced
and 52 percent would be live‑to‑air, people speaking through the
mikes in Drumheller, and the other 48 percent would be voice tracked either by
people in Drumheller ‑‑ you know, like the morning person
probably would voice track the afternoon drive show at the end of ‑‑
you know they would do it during their morning shift. When there is three songs playing they would
start voice tracking 11 o'clock, kind of thing.
Or there may be some person in the Red Deer hub that might do some voice
tracking for the Drumheller station.
199 THE
CHAIRPERSON: So then what percent do you
think of the 48 percent that would be actually done ‑‑ I guess
I'm trying to understand or appreciate is how much is truly reflective of the
people in Drumheller?
200 So if I'm living
in Red Deer ‑‑
201 MR. MURRAY: Yes, I'll let ‑‑ Brent probably
has ‑‑ it varies, I'm sure, day to day and such but Brent can
give you a better ‑‑
202 MR. YOUNG: Yes, our intent with this radio station is to
have about 66 hours a week. So that
would give you a live local and interactive morning show in this market on this
radio station. Also, the same in an
afternoon drive show from three until seven, two until six, and also an hour
over the noon hour.
203 This is all live,
local people in the market to the tune of about 52 percent of the broadcast
week.
204 The remaining
voice tracked hours would be accomplished by people who are already in the
market, people charged to that station or perhaps the announcers who are
already in place at Q91 in Drumheller.
205 There is a sort of
buddy system out of Red Deer where we do have announcers that are specifically
attached to specific markets in our hub.
So should there be an announcer sick or away we have one specific
announcer or a backup behind him or her that's attached to that market. Those people are fed information from the
market, PSA information, weather information, local events, activities, but
they are the synonymous voice in the market when needed. Those are the people out of Red Deer who can
voice track in the market, but typically it's all done locally by the people
who are there.
206 THE
CHAIRPERSON: And the people ‑‑
did I understand you to say that the people doing the voice tracking in Red
Deer are getting the information, so they are getting the information from
Drumheller. So there is that focus.
207 MR. YOUNG: Absolutely, yes, local information,
information of the day. So they are not
just talking about random stuff, as the whole group used to be as a network out
of Edmonton it was very vanilla and across the board whereas now it is very
much spoken to the market by the announcers that are charged with it.
208 THE
CHAIRPERSON: So is this 66 hours then is
that typical for your similar‑sized stations in these smaller Alberta
stations?
209 MR. YOUNG: It is.
The ARG south stations that are in place now all have live, local
morning shows and afternoon drive shows as well and a similar template for the
voice tracking.
210 THE
CHAIRPERSON: And I am taking it you
don't do any syndicated programming?
211 MR. YOUNG: We do not.
212 THE
CHAIRPERSON: No. So the music then, is the music ‑‑
213 MR. YOUNG: Now, let me correct that. I'm sorry.
We do run a four hour Top 40 country countdown show currently as a
syndicated show in weekend airplay on the existing stations.
214 THE
CHAIRPERSON: So who produces that?
215 MR. YOUNG: That is produced through Radio Express. It's a purchased program.
216 THE
CHAIRPERSON: Yes, okay.
217 So the music then
that is played on the station T‑REX 102.7, is it programmed centrally or
is it programmed in Drumheller?
218 MR. YOUNG: That would likely remain to be seen but I
would suspect it will be programmed locally in Drumheller. Currently, they don't have the existing music
scheduling software but they would have to produce it out of there and we have
attached the library too there.
219 We do a lot of
music support currently for our ARG stations only because we have an existing
country station in Red Deer. We don't
have this library in Red Deer and we don't have a database. So we would probably schedule it locally.
220 THE
CHAIRPERSON: So does the capital budget
that you have allowed for this station allow for doing that locally?
221 MR. MURRAY: Yes, we would be doing it locally.
222 THE
CHAIRPERSON: You would be?
223 MR. MURRAY: Yes.
224 THE
CHAIRPERSON: I notice in your brief at
page 8 you state, and I am quoting again:
"...will be supported that
Drumheller FM or T‑REX will be supported in the production of locally‑focused
programming and news targeted exclusively towards the station's own
market." (As read)
225 THE
CHAIRPERSON: So I just would like you to
elaborate if you would on the nature and scope of the programming that they are
going ‑‑ and the synergies between the new FM station and
CKDQ.
226 MS STEVENSON: Currently CKDQ covers the town of Drumheller
itself. It also has a very wide
footprint in the surrounding area. So
they really have a focus on both aspects.
227 With the addition
of three new news people for the news station that would bring our complement
in that newsroom to five which is a significant commitment. It would allow us not only to focus more on
town events and perhaps get to some meetings and events that we haven't been
able to cover.
228 It would also
allow the synergy of allowing Q91 to cover more district news as well. So really it would help in that focus as
well, not just the town but the entire district and we would be able to serve
those markets very well.
229 It would also
allow us to extend the number of newscasts.
We go to six p.m. weekdays with our newscasts. On Q91 currently we only go to five p.m. so
we would be looking at increasing the news content on Q91 as well. We would be able to expand our weekend news
coverage. Currently we have a regional
newscast. It comes out of Edmonton. We would be able to go live, local, weekend
newscasts in Drumheller and that would be, you know, a great benefit to the
community.
230 One of the things
that we would also be able to do is on a regional aspect the newsrooms here you
are talking about the ARG south. We have
a regional hub in Red Deer and we really support each other a lot. We provide a lot of stories to
Drumheller. They provide a lot of
stories to us and it would allow Drumheller to expand their regional news
sharing capabilities with us.
231 And actually,
currently Drumheller actually provides some of our network regional newscasts
that are tailored for that southern Alberta market. Drumheller actually provides some of those
newscasts now for our smaller communities.
So they would be able to expand on their regional news sharing
capabilities as well. So it would be of
significant benefit not only to the community but also our regional ARG South
hub.
232 THE
CHAIRPERSON: I can see that it makes
good business sense to try to get these economies of scale working for you and
the efficiencies. But if I lived in
Drumheller and I switched from AM to FM to listen to the different music would
I hear the same newscast?
233 MS STEVENSON: No.
There is a definite difference in the type of news offered from
Q91. It's a country station. It's agriculture based. There would be a lot of emphasis on
agriculture in that ‑‑ on that station. So you are not going to hear any of that on T‑REX. Frankly, the listeners if they wanted that
they would probably be listening to country music.
234 So there is going
to be a different focus. The town news,
the community news, you are going to hear that on both stations but you have to
make the distinction on what is important to the listeners of each station and
tailor your newscast to that.
235 THE
CHAIRPERSON: Would it be verbatim like
you just play it here and play it there or would it be customized for the other
station?
236 MS STEVENSON: It would have to be customized.
237 THE
CHAIRPERSON: Okay. So the subject might be the same but it
wouldn't be verbatim?
238 MS STEVENSON: You are going to have a different style of
newscast delivery on Q91. It would
probably be a lot more traditional. Over
on T‑REX you might liven it up a little bit and it's definitely a
different style of news read on a station like that. So you would have to rewrite your copy to
reflect that.
239 MR. MURRAY: I should add too that, you know, CKDQ AM is a
50,000 watt AM station. It literally
goes from the Saskatchewan border to Brooks up to Ponoka and over past Calgary
where the T‑REX is only going to serve Drumheller, the 10,000 people down
in the valley.
240 So CKDQ is going
to gather stories from Hanna and Ponoka and Brooks. And you know it's going to get fed stories
because it covers those areas and we take that commitment to serve that whole
area very seriously. T‑REX isn't
going to get there so we are not going to be speaking to those people. We are simply going to be speaking to the
people in Drumheller.
241 THE
CHAIRPERSON: Okay, that adds
clarification.
242 Just as far as
independence of the news, so you are going to have three news people for the
new station.
243 MS STEVENSON: That's correct.
244 THE
CHAIRPERSON: And there is going to be
some sharing, I understand you to be saying but how ‑‑ will they
operate independently? You have
introduced us to your new manager and we have met your current manager for the
AM station.
245 Will they all act
independently?
246 MS STEVENSON: No, it would be a shared newsroom, similar to
what we have in Red Deer where we have two stations. We have one newsroom that services both
stations. I mean to do otherwise it just
wouldn't make sense from a staffing point, a staffing standpoint.
247 So definitely
there would be that sharing of resources and stories and with five news people,
boy, you can get out to a lot of stuff.
248 THE
CHAIRPERSON: I noticed in your October
31st deficiency response to question 7 you indicated that:
"Day to day on air staff would
for the most part be dedicated to one of the two stations." (As read)
249 THE
CHAIRPERSON: And then you go on to say:
"Certain on air positions such
as weekends and off prime periods may be handled by on air staff shared between
the two stations." (As read)
250 THE
CHAIRPERSON: So I was wondering ‑‑
you think I could keep my pages in order here ‑‑ I was
wondering how you will ensure a distinctive sound for T‑REX and CKDQ if
you have the same people shared on the weekend.
251 MR. JONES: We have found in other experiences similar to
this that if the announcers and news people understand who they are talking to
and the purpose of the radio station that talented broadcasters can adapt and
then easily tailor their content to meet the target of each station and
that ‑‑ you know. back to what Dave said about CKDQ being a
regional radio station, doing a shift on that station might involve talking
about highway conditions 100 kilometres away but doing a shift on T‑REX
would mean focusing on the area just of Drumheller.
252 THE
CHAIRPERSON: So now the station manager
or the news director, who is supervised to make ‑‑ who
supervises the on air people to make sure you maintain that flavour?
253 MR. JONES: Well, we have ‑‑ Brent Young
is our program director for Alberta south and oversees all of the programming
staff in those markets. So there is a
program director to look after the on air staff. There is a news director to oversee the news
staff and a general manager at each market to make sure that all of that is
happening as it should.
254 THE
CHAIRPERSON: So there would be two
general managers as I understand it then.
Is that correct?
255 MR. JONES: There is a general manager in Drumheller.
256 And Dave, feel
free to jump in if you like.
257 MR. MURRAY: No, no, you are doing great.
‑‑‑ Laughter /
Rires
258 MR. JONES: I like to focus on music.
259 But there is a
general manager in Drumheller and then there is a regional manager that would
oversee Alberta south and each of the three hubs would have a regional manager.
260 THE
CHAIRPERSON: I like music too but I find
it easier to understand the music than I am understanding the news. So here is the question because you know the
focus is on diversity and news voices.
261 So can you just
sort of sum up for me ‑‑ and I can appreciate the business,
the economic sense of operating it this way and probably it's traditionally
done this way across the country. But I
just want to know how will approving your FM application bring an equal or
greater diversity of news voices to the market versus licensing a new player in
the market?
262 MR. JONES: I think to start with ‑‑ by
licensing our radio station for Drumheller we would be able to increase the
coverage that we provide on both radio stations. This is a very, very small market. I think we have addressed at numerous times in
our presentation to you how difficult it is to provide service to markets that
small and how you need work in economies of scale, and use the regional hubs
for office functions and share those costs in order to make a station like this
feasible.
263 So from a news
perspective another broadcaster may not be able to provide that same level of
service to all the different areas that Q91 does to Drumheller as this station
would.
264 MR. MURRAY: Yes, I think to add to that, you know, I
think ourselves we feel that we can provide a second service in Drumheller, an
FM service, but it would be very difficult to do that in a viable way if we did
not have CKDQ with it's existing sales infrastructure and our existing client
relationships and, you know, all the ‑‑ and the existing news,
these 27 years experienced news people and the Red Deer hub, all the services
that it provides in terms of copy and production and administrative things and
human resource assistance, et cetera, supervision.
265 I think a new
player going into Drumheller but only reaching 8,000 people will have a very
difficult time.
266 THE
CHAIRPERSON: Thank you.
267 My colleagues
might have some questions on that after but I think you have answered
mine. Thank you.
268 The percentage of
revenues, I didn't see that in the information that we were given. What percentage of your revenues do you
expect will come from CKDQ? I gather 2
percent audience share you are saying, but how much of your revenue and what
percentage would come from out‑of‑market stations, new advertisers
to radio or increased spending on the part of current advertisers? Did you do a breakdown or anything of your
revenue?
269 MR. MURRAY: Yes, I think I will ask Ron to talk to our
revenue projection.
270 MR. THOMPSON: Yes, we have taken a very close look at that
because our forecasting is very, very aggressive and what we have looked at is
that from the national viewpoint this format will attract a significant amount
of money and our synergies and relationships with agencies and clients will
cement that in because we can go in as a combo.
Our national is about $200,000 that we are forecasting here. The expanded budgets in the market would be
about $150,000.
271 Some of the
retailers don't have the option of really reaching with the country format that
younger demo that they are looking for.
We are going to be getting a significant amount of money from new
advertisers.
272 There is a lot of
interest in reaching those people in Drumheller. They are small but mighty and that's ‑‑
the breakdown is basically about ‑‑ the migration from Q91
will be about $200,000 to $250,000. We
realize that.
273 THE
CHAIRPERSON: Thank you.
274 Yes, I know that
at other hearings we have asked this question, this next question, with regards
to your projection of audience shares, you know the 21 percent flat over the
seven years. So now that I have heard it
asked before I just am curious to know, is that your actual experience that
that is what will happen, 21 percent in year one and then ‑‑
275 MR. JONES: Yes, we have found in markets that are under
serviced that a new station can sign on and make an immediate impact. There are listeners out there who are hungry
for the format and they will find this very quickly, especially in a smaller
market.
276 There is very
little doubt that once this radio station signs on there will be a tremendous
buzz in the market because there is a huge group of people who don't have a
radio station to serve them. We wouldn't
expect that to ramp up over time. That
will happen right away, and that's clear in our research that we did in looking
at this market.
277 THE
CHAIRPERSON: Same answer I heard before,
I think.
‑‑‑ Laughter /
Rires
278 THE
CHAIRPERSON: Consistency counts for a
lot.
279 I notice because
we have some comparisons that compare your projections to similar‑sized
markets that your sales and promotion costs and your admin in general costs as
a percent of total revenue are lower than comparable sized markets. And I am assuming ‑‑ I guess
I shouldn't answer the question. I will
let you answer the question.
280 MR. MURRAY: Yes, that's right. I mean it's because of our Alberta south hub
will provide some services to ‑‑ they do provide services to
CKDQ AM now and they will also provide them to T‑REX and it's not ‑‑
they won't be charged to T‑REX. We
don't have to add a number of people in Red Deer to put T‑REX on the air
but they can do some if they can do the same service as they are providing for
the other stations in the southern hub.
281 MS SPENRATH: And if I might add, actually, disbanding the
ARG head office on January 1st, 2008 there is probably about another maybe
$150,000 in costs that really do belong to the south and will be in ‑‑
you know, charged to them next year, primarily engineering; a little bit of
sales and some administrative costs as well.
282 THE
CHAIRPERSON: So I understand from what
was said earlier that it would probably end up showing up in Red Deer, not in
Drumheller.
283 MS SPENRATH: Well, this is over and above Red Deer. This is what was left of what's coming out of
Edmonton with ARG head office which was disbanded just on January 1st of
'08. So there will be some extra costs
that really do belong to Drumheller that will be charged out at that time that
you will see split partially in '08 and a full year's worth annualized in '09,
2009.
284 THE
CHAIRPERSON: And are those in the
forecast that you have given us? Are
they in the projections that you have given us?
Are they allowed for in those?
285 MS SPENRATH: Yes, they are.
286 THE
CHAIRPERSON: Okay, thank you.
287 I just wanted to
switch to Canadian Content Development.
And I am just wondering if you are willing ‑‑ well, if
Newcap is willing to accept the imposition of a transitionary Canadian Content
Development condition of licence which will expire with the amendments to
the ‑‑ when the amendments to the Radio Regulations come into
force?
288 MR. MURRAY: Yes, we do.
289 MS SPENRATH: Yes.
Yes, we are. Thank you.
290 THE
CHAIRPERSON: And with regards to the
October 31st deficiency response to question six you indicate that you have
received written confirmation from the Drumheller District School Board that
they will comply with the policies.
291 MR. MURRAY: Yes.
292 THE
CHAIRPERSON: Did you file that with the
Commission or would you?
293 MR. MURRAY: Yes, we can.
294 THE
CHAIRPERSON: You will, okay. Thanks.
295 MR. MURRAY: I will file it this week.
296 THE
CHAIRPERSON: Thank you.
297 And I'm just
wondering what if any follow‑up measures you will have in place with the
school board to monitor and ensure that the funding continues to be spent in
accordance with the CCD eligibility criteria.
298 MS SPENRATH: Yes, actually, part of my job is to follow up
on all of the CCD spending to make sure that it's qualified.
299 We do normally
speak to schools ahead of time, prior to disbursing the funds, and do get a
letter from them confirming that it will be spent. And I do talk to them and let them know what
types of things qualify for a CCD.
300 THE
CHAIRPERSON: So do you do that like on
an annual basis periodically, not just at the outset?
301 MS SPENRATH: Depends on the decision, because some like
Calgary and Ottawa are very detailed and ongoing. So I am in constant conversations with the
people. On ones like this where it is an
annual contribution it would be once a year.
302 THE
CHAIRPERSON: Okay. So you would talk to them at least once a
year?
303 MS SPENRATH: Oh, yes.
304 THE
CHAIRPERSON: Okay. No, that's fine then.
305 I noticed at page
13 of your brief, and maybe your plans have changed a bit ‑‑
you mention, and I am quoting again, that your CCD:
"...includes a significant
component considered specifically to enhance opportunities for Aboriginal
people." (As read)
306 THE
CHAIRPERSON: But when I look at the
table it's not obvious to me where that is.
307 MS SPENRATH: Again, that's something where when we
communicate ‑‑ because I spoke to two different principals in
the two different school systems, Catholic and public, and we do communicate to
them that we would like these opportunities made available, you know, at first
to Aboriginal students if possible, if there is an opportunity in their school
and then, you know, second to the general school population.
308 THE
CHAIRPERSON: I don't know what portion
of the population in Drumheller would be Aboriginal, a very high percentage?
309 MS SPENRATH: Yes, according to Stats Canada 2006 it's 5
percent.
310 THE
CHAIRPERSON: Thank you.
311 Now, I am
interested in your emerging technologies and you named quite a few that you
expect to be using. And I'm wondering
which ones you are currently using in systems of this size because I'm sure in
your larger systems you are doing a lot of these things, but you had indicated
internet streaming, podcasting, on demand streams to cellular phones.
312 MR. JONES: Well, the on demand streams to cellular
phones is ‑‑
313 THE
CHAIRPERSON: Coming?
314 MR. JONES: ‑‑
certainly something for the future.
315 As it stands now,
almost all of our stations coast to coast stream their live feed on the
internet. Numerous radio stations in our
group podcast, put up specific programs for download. Some of our radio stations offer large
portions of their programming on demand, not specifically a podcast but an MP3
file that you can download for your iPod or MP3 player or on your computer.
316 A lot of our radio
stations also have taken advantage of the Youtube phenomenon and created video
streaming on their websites so when the radio station does a promotion or a
stunt or something interesting they can actually provide video coverage.
317 Maybe Brent or Sue
might like to elaborate a bit on Red Deer because that's been ‑‑our
ARG south hub, Red Deer, has been one of the leading stations in our group to
take advantage of that technology.
318 MR. YOUNG: Yes, we offer quite a service on the two Red
Deer properties. One is called Z TV and
the other KG TV and we actually have a professional shooter who comes from TV
who now works independently. And he sort
of follows us around to different promotions, comes in and shoots our morning
show just on a whim when they are doing interesting stuff or in the public at
events.
319 You know, our Golf
To Cure Kids cancer fundraiser, we'll shoot the golf tournament, compile a mini
TV show, upload it to our website and people can watch it and we're talking
about it on air. And we direct them to
the website so they can put a face to the name and that sort of stuff.
320 THE
CHAIRPERSON: So this is somebody you
actually engaged? You hire him to do
that? It's not like a volunteer.
321 MR. YOUNG: Correct.
He is freelance and works alongside us.
This is his business. He has many
other projects and works with us exclusively in the radio market for our two
stations.
322 THE
CHAIRPERSON: I'm curious to know how you
are monetizing these opportunities at this point and how you see you will be
able to do that in the future.
323 MR. JONES: Monetizing the internet for radio stations is
something that really just started in the last couple of years and we haven't
derived a significant amount yet from these emerging technologies, although you
know it definitely will grow into the future.
324 Right now the main
purpose of what we do on the internet is to connect with the listener and
connect with the community. But
definitely there are opportunities in terms of client sponsorships or
videotaping or broadcasting events at client locations. Web streams offer the opportunity to run
video ads prior to your web audio feed starting, so there can be some
opportunity there for revenue as well as SMS and text messaging. That does generate some revenue.
325 At this point I
don't know a percentage but it's very insignificant considering the entire
revenue pool, but it's one that's going to grow in the future.
326 THE CHAIRPERSON: Is it something that your sales force is
putting an emphasis on or that you're directing them to explore?
327 MR. MURRAY: We have more or less found that the existing
radio sales force really don't understand the internet. And what Steve is talking about is, you know,
the way we ‑‑ we are interested in reaching out to the
listeners in whatever ways we can to provide more service so that they have
faith in us and et cetera.
328 So we do sell
banner ads on our stations and more or less there would be a special person or
a single person in Alberta that would sell all the websites because it is a
different understanding of, you know, clicks, page views and all those sort of
things.
329 THE
CHAIRPERSON: I'm sure as your listeners
mature and become employees then you will realize more money and more revenue
from it, I would think.
330 MR. MURRAY: Yes, I would like to get more revenue from
it.
331 THE
CHAIRPERSON: Yes, I am sure the
potential is there.
332 MR. MURRAY: If you have any ideas.
‑‑‑ Laughter /
Rires
333 MR. JONES: Just to summarize a bit of that, we have
created too just this year a new media kind of taskforce within our company and
have taken a lot of our younger employees who have grown up with all of this
technology and recognized that they use it differently than some of us older
folk do.
‑‑‑ Laughter /
Rires
334 MR. JONES: And so we have tried to tap into that
knowledge base and that will help us as we grow, make sure that we are
capitalizing both from a listener service point of view and potentially from a
revenue point of view on these technologies.
335 THE
CHAIRPERSON: Excellent, thank you.
336 Now, I'm sort of
winding down on my questions here, but I'm wondering how many new licensees you
think the market could support.
337 MR. MURRAY: Well, I think I have sort of tried to answer
that a little bit before in saying that I think, you know, Drumheller itself
with only ‑‑ and I notice our signal reaches 8,500 people, the
other ones reach approximately 8,000 ‑‑ will be a very
challenging market to produce a viable sustaining service. We can do it.
You know we have an advantage because of our Alberta south hub and the
existing CDKQ AM.
338 So you know,
really, we just want you to licence us.
‑‑‑ Laughter /
Rires
339 THE
CHAIRPERSON: That's clear.
340 MR. MURRAY: But seriously, you know, we think we do have
a leg up but we are comfortable with your decision if you think there is
more. There is obviously two
frequencies. The people of Drumheller
deserve more service. So we are pretty
comfortable with whatever you do.
341 THE
CHAIRPERSON: Thank you very much. Thank you.
342 Panel?
343 Commissioner
Cugini will start.
344 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: Thank you, Madam Chair.
345 Okay, Mr. Jones,
now we are going to talk about music.
346 MR. JONES: Excellent.
347 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: I am looking at your playlist
and I am just wondering, were you thinking about CCD when you wrote Cindi
Lauper, Girls Just Want to Have Fund?
‑‑‑ Laughter /
Rires
348 MR. JONES: That may have been a subconscious kind of
typo.
349 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: That's okay.
350 I mean, I heard
what you said in your opening presentation about how much people love country
music and they listen to it a lot. And
there is in fact a lot of out‑of‑market tuning to the country stations
in Calgary.
351 Where are your
potential listeners getting this music that you have on your playlist today?
352 MR. JONES: For the most part I think right now they are
getting it from JACK‑FM in Calgary.
It's the most similar‑sounding radio station in the region and
it's the nearest geographic radio station.
But Drumheller is in a valley that is very deep and when you go into
that valley you lose reliable reception of almost any out‑of‑market
signal.
353 So it does speak
to the desire for this kind of music or for some kind of choice that there is
the kind of out‑of‑market tuning there is because it's not a
reliable reception.
354 I think JACK‑FM
is the primary source. They may also be
hearing some of this on web streams from different radio stations and that we
really don't know.
355 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: Do you find that country music
listeners are more adaptable in terms of a classic hits format as opposed to an
alternative rock format for Drumheller?
356 MR. JONES: Well, certainly there is a lot more crossover
in tuning. We find in many different
experiences as we research the country that classic hits listeners, some rock
listeners and country listeners do share a little bit in common, certainly more
than they would with an alternative rock or a younger leaning radio
station. Country listeners tend to be a
bit more conservative in their tastes and a lot more passionate about country
music, at least a lot more passionate pro country music.
357 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: I mean you don't have ‑‑
well, you might. You might include some
elements of classic rock in this format.
Do you find that that is more akin to country listeners as well?
358 MR. JONES: Yes, there is definitely crossover between
classic ‑‑ there is a generation of people who grew up on the
Eagles and Linda Ronstadt and Fleetwood Mac and the Doobie Brothers and the
Steve Miller Band and Guess Who, who got to an era in the eighties and nineties
and found that their music ‑‑ the music that was being made
didn't sound anything like what they grew up with. And there is that new generation of country
that emerged in the nineties that repatriated a lot of those people over to
country music with Garth Brooks and a whole new country sound that emerged in
the mid‑nineties. So we do see some
crossover between classic rock and country.
359 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: And I know I have asked you guys
this before but refresh my memory.
360 Again, on your
playlist you have got the far right column "GRC" classification. Is it current, recurrence ‑‑
361 MR. JONES: And gold.
362 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: And gold?
363 MR. JONES: Yes.
364 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: That's it, okay.
365 MR. JONES: And we have ‑‑ we have
included a few, you know, currents that if there were a different market, if
this were a market where you had 20 signals we probably wouldn't be so inclined
to include them. But in a market like
Drumheller where you need to be more broad we have included an element of new
music in our format that you might not see if this were an application before
you in Calgary. You know we have
included about 10 percent new music and of that we have committed 4 percent
emerging artists.
366 We have a program
in Ottawa and Calgary, our CCB programs there, the Big Money Shot in Ottawa,
the Big Rock Star in Calgary that actively generate new music. And seeing as Drumheller lives kind of in the
shadow of Calgary I think there is a great synergy there for artists who enter
the rock star program at CFUL‑FM in Calgary to either come from
Drumheller or if they are not from Drumheller to receive exposure in the
market.
367 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: Would you put somebody like
Crash Parallel on this station?
368 MR. JONES: Yes.
369 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: Okay, thank you. That gives me a better idea what the station
is going to sound like.
370 I just have one
more question on the spoken word, and I'm not sure if Ms Stevenson or Mr.
Murray, you want to answer this question.
371 When I look at
what you have given to us this morning with your oral remarks, something like
Community Action, Crime Stoppers, Drumheller Hobs, Business Report, Local
Heroes, almost look like and sound like they could be vignettes on this
station.
372 MS STEVENSON: Some of them would be, especially the
Community Action. It would be like a one‑minute
update where a local charity or group comes into the station and in their own
voice would tell the community about their program or, you know, what they are
proposing to do and things like that. So
that would be a vignette, so to speak.
373 Crime Stoppers
very much along the same lines. It would
not just be your average, you know, the police come in and they are looking for
this crime of the week. It would also
include crime prevention tips, block parents, anything like that; community
tips on how to keep safe. So that would
also be a vignette.
374 What's On would
probably be more like a PSA‑type thing that would be handled by the
announcers. The business report, again,
would include both local business. You
might talk to ‑‑ it's a very big oil, energy service site in
Drumheller, plus agriculture, so you may be talking to some local people but
also having the Alberta and national business news included in that; so really
a conglomeration of a bunch of different elements for those.
375 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: And are these features available currently on
your AM station?
376 MS STEVENSON: Of course the PSAs are, and we would make
those available to Q91 if they are not.
The current announcers on Q91 of course do a lot of community interviews
already and, you know, so it's in a different format but it is there.
377 Crime Stoppers
would be a new feature and The Business Report would also be new.
378 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: And Local Heroes as well?
379 MS STEVENSON: Yes, Local Heroes the same thing. That already though is included, you know, in
a more informal way on air on Q91, just not as a set program.
380 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: So this would be additional
spoken word available to the market?
381 MS STEVENSON: It would be.
382 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: And if your AM station wanted
access to them, they could become available to them?
383 MS STEVENSON: I think ‑‑
384 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: And would that be in addition to
their current level though ‑‑ to that station's current level
of spoken word ‑‑
385 MS STEVENSON: Yes.
386 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: ‑‑ or in place of?
387 MS STEVENSON: Maybe Brent would like to speak to that.
388 MR. YOUNG: It obviously would be, but I think in more of
a formal manner. As to Sue's points,
those elements are already there, but not so much in a formal manner listed in
place.
389 They certainly
could be.
390 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: Okay. Thank you very much.
391 Thank you, Madam
Chair. Those are my questions.
392 THE
CHAIRPERSON: Commissioner Menzies.
393 COMMISSIONER
MENZIES: Thanks.
394 I'll try to make
it quick because you've been there for a while.
395 What's the margin
of error on a survey of 150 people?
396 MR. JONES: I would have to go back and check and submit
that to you separately. We don't have
that with me.
397 However, a survey
of 150 people in a market of 8,000, we know ‑‑ we were before
the Commission in Vancouver with a survey in the 500 range I believe for a
market of several million, so on a sliding scale 150 would be the kind of panel
size we would look for.
398 If we were doing
general strategic research in this market ourselves and, you know, it was for
our own internal purposes, a panel of 150 in a market that size wouldn't be out
of line with what we'd normally consider.
399 COMMISSIONER
MENZIES: Okay. You don't need to get back with the exact
number to me, I just wanted to ‑‑ you answered my question and
that you were confident in the accuracy of your research.
400 MR. JONES: Okay.
401 COMMISSIONER
MENZIES: Just at the start you touched
on this a little bit earlier, but I just wanted to go back to it again.
402 News, you'd be
adding three people ‑‑ there's already ‑‑
there's two at your AM, you'd be adding three people.
403 Give me some sort
of ‑‑ and, again, this doesn't have to be a fixed thing, just
a stronger ballpark idea. How many new
stories would be getting done as opposed to five people doing the same stories
that two people are doing now?
404 MS STEVENSON: We would not have the people working on the
same story. That just wouldn't make sense,
you would be able to cover so many more
items, and the news people would be responsible for all these vignettes
that we spoke about: the business report, you know, the community profiles, the
local heroes. So, perhaps one person may
be dedicated to that area to expand on that.
405 We would be able
to expand our sports coverage, the Drumheller Dragons of the Alberta Junior
Hockey League, you know, from the local soccer teams. So, we would be able to expand on that area
as well.
406 COMMISSIONER MENZIES: So, all the story assignments would be
centrally coordinated, for instance?
407 MS STEVENSON: Definitely out of Drumheller, they would do
that.
408 COMMISSIONER
MENZIES: So, it's more like the
expansion of a single newsroom than the addition of another newsroom?
409 MS STEVENSON: That's correct. It would be a cohesive unit acting together
with a localized news director who would be handing out the assignments.
410 COMMISSIONER
MENZIES: Right. Now, just in terms of economic growth for the
area, what do you see in the future for the Drumheller area in terms of
opportunities for economic growth?
411 What I'm trying to
do is get a sense of, if you weren't already in this market, would you want to
go into it because of its future?
412 MR. MURRAY: I think we would because we're all around it,
for sure. So, you know, we're very
excited to have ‑‑ possibly have an opportunity to provide
this extra service.
413 Clearly the AM
probably gives us an opportunity to actually make some money eight or nine years
from now.
414 But clearly
Drumheller is a small community, you
know, 10,000 people, it ‑‑ I guess I answered.
415 We would be trying
to get in here.
416 COMMISSIONER
MENZIES: Okay. And are there any specific areas that you see
the economy growing? I mean, Alberta
overall has a good economy, but the Drumheller area isn't necessarily at the
heart of it and the conventional oil and gas industry.
417 MR. MURRAY: Right.
418 COMMISSIONER
MENZIES: And the drilling activity is on
a much different curve than the oil sands and new oil industry.
419 Agriculture is
always questionable.
420 I'm just wondering
where you see ‑‑ do you see the economy kind of staying as it
is.
421 MR. MURRAY: Yes.
422 COMMISSIONER
MENZIES: Or do you see it curving
upwards?
423 MR. MURRAY: Yeah.
424 COMMISSIONER
MENZIES: Or do you see it sliding down?
425 MR. MURRAY: I think I'll ask Ron to comment because he's
more in touch with southern Alberta than I would be.
426 MR. THOMPSON: The local economy is going to be leaning heavier
on the tourist industry and we're seeing that.
Like, there's some beautiful hotels there, it's a big part of what they
do and they have one of the ‑‑ well, the only dinosaur museum
in Canada type of a thing.
427 But we see growth
there, but it's going to be steady. It's
a work horse not a race horse.
428 COMMISSIONER
MENZIES: Okay.
429 MR. THOMPSON: But there's a tremendous amount of confidence
in the market by the local people that are there and they do draw from around
Drumheller, their services are good.
430 But the growth I
believe, because of the cost of gas and so forth, it is a very attractive place
to go to and they've got very great ‑‑ you know, good
facilities. So, I see tourism.
431 The oil and gas
and agriculture is always going to be cyclical, but it's not going to die, it
will just ‑‑ it won't be the major focus there.
432 COMMISSIONER
MENZIES: Okay. And sort of last in this, and there's ‑‑
I don't have ‑‑ I'm just going to preface this by saying
there's no right answer or no wrong answer, I think both of these
strategies ‑‑ and there might be a different one ‑‑
but I think both of them are just fine, make a lot of business sense.
433 But what I'm just
trying to get at overall in these last two questions is: Is your strategy with this an offensive
growth strategy in terms of expansion, or is it fundamentally a defensive
strategy to make sure that if the market ‑‑ if there's going
to be additional growth in the market that you have it and it protects your AM?
434 MR. MURRAY: Right.
Clearly there's some of that, but when we purchased the Alberta Radio
Group in 2002 we had a very specific plan.
435 Practically all of
them were AM stations and we had a strong belief in Alberta and we had a strong
belief in radio in Alberta.
436 So, what we've
done, we've virtually upgraded every single studio location. We've moved most of those facility into new
facilities. We've upgraded all the
transmitter facilities which includes conversion of four of the AMs to FM
already.
437 We have an additional
three applications ready to file for additional conversions.
438 We've also been
successful at applying for three new FM services in the Alberta Radio Group in
these rural markets in Camrose, Wainwright and Brooks and at a cost of
approximately $5‑million so far.
439 So, we're
looking ‑‑ you know, we're very ‑‑ and I also
mentioned already about, you know, eliminating that network programming and
turning programming that used to be ‑‑ used to come out of
Edmonton and it was exactly the same in every single market, after morning
drive, is now 100 per cent local in every single market.
440 Some of that is
voice track because you have to do that in these little markets in order to be
viable and provide that excellent service.
441 So, I think ‑‑
I hope I'm answering your question, to say we're committed to Alberta and we
would be applying in Drumheller, even if we weren't there, but we think it's a
huge advantage because we're there.
442 COMMISSIONER
MENZIES: Okay. Thank you very much.
443 THE CHAIRPERSON: Commissioner Patrone has some questions.
444 COMMISSIONER
PATRONE: Thank you, Madam Chair.
445 I wanted to ask
first off about your future classics program, that's your sort of venue for
newer artists; is that correct?
446 Is that an hour‑long
segment, and when does it air?
447 MR. JONES: The positioning of these songs as future
classics is not intended to be a program per se, but it's just a regular
element of our programming.
448 So, if 10 percent
of our music is new then, you know, one in every 10 songs would be positioned
on the air as a future classic.
449 And it's a way of
positioning these songs in the context of classic hits so they don't sound of
place. And the future classics supports
us that opportunity again to feed from the big money shot and the big rock star
programs.
450 And those are very
ambitious programs in Calgary and Ottawa that have a tremendous output of new
music and that was the whole purpose behind them, was to actually
generate ‑‑ to put together a CCD initiative that actually
generated new CDs, new MP3s, new bands who are getting recorded and distributed
to radio.
451 By doing this in
Drumheller, by including that 10 per cent new music and four per cent emerging
artists as we've called them future classics, we really I think give a leg up
to bands in that area. And there is
music being made even in a small town like Drumheller.
452 Nickelback, for
example, came from Hanna, Alberta which is within the Q‑91 area and I can
only imagine what a success they could have been had we already been there,
but...
‑‑‑ Laughter /
Rires
453 MR. JONES: Of course, that's hindsight, but there's more
to come and we can be part of that.
454 COMMISSIONER
PATRONE: On what basis are those songs
chosen?
455 MR. JONES: The 10 percent of our new music would be
chosen by our local program director.
And generally what will happen is there will be a weekly meeting, music
meeting with the on‑air staff and they'll go through the new music and
decide which is format compatible.
456 In the case of the
big money shot and the big rock star programs, those are probably the rare
instances where we as a company will corporately say that these songs are
priorities and should be given air play and there isn't a lot of, you know,
local decision‑making on those songs, those are given air play.
457 The other ones,
you know, whether or not to play the new Bruce Springsteen song right away or
wait a few weeks is a local decision.
458 COMMISSIONER
PATRONE: Now, Psychedelic Sundays,
that's produced ‑‑ is that produced locally or is that the
same show that's produced elsewhere
then canned for all your stations?
459 MR. YOUNG: Yeah, not correct. No, all of those shows would be locally
produced as they have to fit into the template that's designed for the market.
460 Currently we
don't ‑‑ we have a lot of feature programming on existing
radio stations, but nothing is made here, shipped there.
461 COMMISSIONER
PATRONE: And I know in your Halifax
station you have ‑‑ your morning drive time, your morning
announcer, one of the three also does their newscast.
462 Is that an
approach that you're considering here?
463 MS STEVENSON: We would have dedicated news people. They would not be in most circumstances
involved in on‑air.
464 COMMISSIONER
PATRONE: Okay.
465 MS STEVENSON: The exception to that would be when there is
breaking news after hours. Those news
announcers are cross‑trained to be able to go on air and provide live and
local coverage to any breaking news.
466 Basically right
now we have news people in our stations between 4:00 a.m. and 6:00 p.m. on
weekdays and, when they are not in the station, they are on call.
467 So, you know, so
we would be breaking into local programming that way.
468 COMMISSIONER
PATRONE: And how much actual field
reporting are your reporters going to do out of Drumheller? I mean, are they going to be spending most of
their time working the phones inside the newsroom, or are they going to get an
opportunity to get out into the community and really file from out there?
469 MS STEVENSON: They would ‑‑ and, you know,
that changes every given day depending on what the news of that day is. But generally you try and get out to the
local school boards, the local hospital board meeting, the town hall, the
Chamber of Commerce, because you are the face of that radio station.
470 So, the more that
you can get out in the community and interact with them, it's just so much
better than sitting in the radio station on the phone.
471 COMMISSIONER
PATRONE: And those reporters will be
working the courts as well and town hall...?
472 MS STEVENSON: They would be covering court cases,
everything that's available, all the normal duties that you would cover, plus
they would try and find smaller events, multicultural BBQs, that might be
something that they would go to cover as well.
473 Given such a big
news staff, you would have the opportunity to get to some of those smaller
events that perhaps you just have to give a miss to now with a smaller news
staff, so...
474 COMMISSIONER
PATRONE: Will it be subscribing to a
news service like BN or will it be part of the ‑‑
475 MS STEVENSON: Yeah.
476 COMMISSIONER
PATRONE: ‑‑ region‑wide system?
477 MS STEVENSON: The station in Drumheller is hooked up to
Canadian Press, so ‑‑ which is changed from BN now ‑‑
so, you know, they have the news wire and the audio from Canadian Press.
478 We also support
them from Red Deer with any
provincial stories that we do out of Red Deer or that have a regional focus, we
send down our newsroom program to them, so they have that extra resource.
479 And, conversely,
anything that they produce in Drumheller that is of a regional focus, they send
to us.
480 COMMISSIONER
PATRONE: Will you be able to go live
from the legislature or anything like that?
481 MS STEVENSON: We do have a reporter here in Edmonton who
covers like city hall and the legislature.
We have gone live with them during elections and, so, that capability
would be there.
482 COMMISSIONER
PATRONE: A couple more. Your agribusiness segment, that is a separate
segment; is that correct, and how long does that run?
483 MS STEVENSON: That is.
That runs ‑‑ we have an actual couple of elements to
that. It runs in the morning, there's
about a two‑minute report that runs after the 6:30 and 7:30 news.
484 In the noon hour,
that's expanded on Q‑91 and it runs about 25 minutes and includes market
reports, in‑depth agriculture news, but it runs about 25 minutes after
that noon hour news package.
485 COMMISSIONER
PATRONE: Is that a sponsored segment?
486 MS STEVENSON: There are different sponsors. You know, it could be anyone from a farm
implement dealer to fertilizer, so definitely, you know.
487 But keep in mind
that would not be travelling over to T‑Rex because that would stay on Q‑91
being agriculture based.
488 COMMISSIONER
PATRONE: Yes. I ask about the sponsorship issue because, of
course, there's always the issue of editorial fairness which I know, you know,
you're obviously aware of.
489 I mean, if you're
doing a segment that is supposed to be a news segment but it's sponsored by XYZ
Fertilizer and you're doing a fertilizer story, I mean, it can blur the lines.
490 MS STEVENSON: Yeah.
That doesn't really come into
play if it's news, it's basically on, and we don't ‑‑ you
know, we're not pulling back because of who our sponsors are.
491 If that answers
your question.
492 COMMISSIONER
PATRONE: Yeah. What oversight do you have to ensure that
that, in fact, takes place?
493 MS STEVENSON: Twenty‑seven years of experience with
the news people in the market. So, you
know, it's a common sense issue.
494 COMMISSIONER
PATRONE: Any plans to hire stringers,
part‑timers, volunteer reporters, that sort of thing?
495 MS STEVENSON: No.
496 COMMISSIONER
PATRONE: Those are my questions. Thank you, Madam Chair.
497 THE
CHAIRPERSON: Thank you.
498 COMMISSIONER
MOLNAR: Thank you.
499 There's been a lot
of information shared here and so many of my questions have been answered, but
I have a couple. One is simply a follow
up to the discussion there was on new media, new distribution platforms.
500 You spoke of some
of the initiatives you're taking in Red Deer, the YouTube and so on and you
made the comment, and I'm sorry I forget which of you made the comment that the
Internet allows you to connect with your listener and with your community.
501 And, you know, it
was a very fulsome discussion, but I didn't leave with actual understanding of
what your particular plans were to use new distribution platforms such as the
Internet and, you know, streaming or podcasting or what as it relates
particularly to the market of Drumheller.
502 MR. JONES: Our plan in Drumheller would be similar to
the plans we have in place across the country, and that is to provide ‑‑
we provide a corporate platform for
our local radio stations to provide all this content.
503 Our stations in
Newfoundland have a weekly program that they do. It's going to sound a little out of place
because it's a very local context program, but every weekend they send a guy
out to broadcast live in a shed and he goes to back yards and streets and
parties and lakes and wherever he might go, and they had the premier, Premier
Williams in the shed with them and they record that and put that up on their
website for listeners to view and download.
504 If there's
particular events, as Brent mentioned, the Run for Cancer, to have the finish
line video taped and interviews with the winners and sponsors and to bring that
up on our website.
505 Those are the kind
of local‑based video webstreaming initiatives we would use.
506 Again, it really
does provide ‑‑ it's a local ‑‑ it's a local
decision what sort of events happen in the community and they can utilize audio
and video on the Internet. Those
platforms are provided to them.
507 And, in addition,
the very basic one is streaming our audio content. The listeners in Drumheller will be able to
listen to the radio station on air or online, and if they choose to travel and
want to stay in touch with their favourite radio station, it will be available
to them 24/7 on the Internet.
508 COMMISSIONER
MOLNAR: You said it was a local decision
as to what goes on air. So, if the
Drumheller radio station wanted to have a fulsome, rich website to promote and
cross‑promote and support the community, who in the market would be
making those decisions?
509 MR. JONES: We have local people making those decisions
in the market. Our program directors
would generally do that.
510 If there's news
implications, our news directors would have a say in that and they would work
with our corporate web team based in Halifax who build these platforms for
them, and all of our radio stations have very rich websites to serve their
communities.
511 MR. MURRAY: Yeah.
I think specifically to answer your question, they would have a website,
they would be streaming, because we provide that corporately. What they put on it in terms of specific
content, they would make the decision, but they would have many examples from
our other 50 some radio stations across the country. They would have a access to those and, you
know, Steve would have program director meetings and things of that nature.
512 So, they would be
getting ideas from our stations plus many other sources of training and, you
know, radio training programs related to programming around the world.
513 COMMISSIONER
MOLNAR: Okay. Thank you.
514 My last
question. I wanted to speak of cultural
diversity and I've heard a couple of comments about it.
515 I guess first, as
the incumbent within Drumheller, perhaps you could help me in explaining to me
what is the cultural make‑up of the market that you operate in?
516 MS SPENRATH: Yes.
In Drumheller itself the representation of Aboriginal and visible
minority peoples is five per cent each, which is slightly less than the
provincial average in both cases. And as
far as Aboriginal communities, or First Nations communities, there aren't any
really close, Bassano would be the closest.
They're all in sort of Treaty 7 area.
Most of them are in southern Alberta, so, most of those people would be
right in the Drumheller...
517 COMMISSIONER
MOLNAR: So, a relatively small
diverse ‑‑ from an ethnocultural or persons of Aboriginal
descent or persons with disability, it's a relatively small percentage of the
Drumheller marketplace?
518 MS SPENRATH: Yes, relatively small in relation to Alberta.
519 COMMISSIONER
MOLNAR: Okay.
520 MS SPENRATH: Probably on the Aboriginal side it is close
to the national average, and certainly under the national and provincial
average for visible minority peoples and
people with disabilities. There isn't detailed information by town or
by city for that, we have to look to the provincial.
521 COMMISSIONER
MOLNAR: You say within your
supplementary brief, and I'll just read it here, it says:
"In terms of programming, our
music, news and spoken word will reinforce our commitment to both the presence
and portrayal of Canada's cultural diversity." (As read)
522 COMMISSIONER
MOLNAR: So, could you tell me what it is
particularly in your plans that would reflect this within your on‑air programming?
523 MS SPENRATH: Yes.
And even though the population in this particular community is less than
the average, we certainly take it seriously and would devote the same efforts
there as we do in all of our markets.
524 As far as
programming goes, our cultural diversity initiatives include, you know,
developing, building relationships with all the various communities that fall
within our areas that we would broadcast, making sure that when we're
doing ‑‑ bringing guests in on air that we're being representative
of the community that we're serving and, I guess, just making sure that our
staff is representative of the diversity of the area.
525 We do do workshops
for our people to talk about, particularly people with recruiting
responsibilities about what the requirements are for cultural diversity. So, they've all been educated on what our
responsibilities are as broadcasters to ensure that our product is culturally
diverse and represents and is relevant to the people that we're broadcasting
to.
526 MR. JONES: We also, if I may, reach out in each market
to groups and associations that exist and let them know that the radio station
is available to them for public service, make sure that we're on their
distribution list for news releases and press releases so that we can...
527 I think a lot of
people, when English isn't your first language, will assume that the radio
station, because it's in English, isn't open to you, and letting people know
that their events matter and their news releases matter and making sure that
we're available to them is important.
528 COMMISSIONER
MOLNAR: You know, I certainly agree, and
I think particularly in small markets where there is only one or two radio
stations there's a bit of a responsibility to ensure that you're, you know,
relevant to all of the marketplace and all the different cultural...
529 So, from that end
I'll just ask, are there any particular programs, any particular initiatives
or, you know, structured parts of your operations of the radio station that would
be directed particularly to any of the culturally diverse groups?
530 MS SPENRATH: I'll maybe speak
corporately and then maybe I'll ask,
you know ‑‑
531 COMMISSIONER
MOLNAR: And fair enough, I think I would
speak about Drumheller.
532 MS SPENRATH: Oh, okay.
533 COMMISSIONER
MOLNAR: If that's okay, you know, for
this radio station that we're planning.
534 MS SPENRATH: Sure.
I guess I can speak corporately and maybe I'll have either Brent or
Steve talk ‑‑ or even Sue talk about specific features that
may take that into consideration.
535 Corporately we do
ask that each of our locations report monthly on any activities, any news
stories, events that they may cover that do ‑‑ that would be
of interest or relevant to a diverse audience member.
536 Sue...
537 MR. JONES: On a local level, as far as structure, no,
there's not ‑‑ outside of reporting what you're doing and
having someone at the corporate level contacting you regularly saying, what are
you doing, how are you being
responsible to your community?
538 That's probably
the biggest structural initiative that we have, and that does exist on the
local level even though it's a corporate initiative.
539 But back to ‑‑
I think it's worth going back to the point about reaching out and making sure
that for our local heroes segment or for our what's on segment that we're
celebrating the cultural diversity, the festivals, the meetings, the events
that are important.
540 And then from a
public service point of view, reaching out to the local community whether or
not the particular events impact their particular ethnic group, things like the
earthquake in China and the situation in Burma, and those things that happen
around the world, having a radio station on a local level who can bring
together to the community, to reach out and assist in those things is very
important.
541 COMMISSIONER
MOLNAR: Thank you. Those are my questions.
542 THE
CHAIRPERSON: Thank you. Counsel has some questions for you.
543 MR. MORRIS: Thanks.
544 Just a couple of
small points of clarification.
545 In your sheet that
you submitted today which breaks down the spoken word programming you've
committed to news programming for four hours and 46 minutes.
546 I just wanted
to ‑‑ does that include surveillance like weather and sports
and traffic updates, or is that pure news?
547 MS SPENRATH: That's a combination of news, weather and
sports. The weather surveillance that
you're speaking of would fall into the next section in the six hour, 18 minute.
548 MR. MORRIS: So, there's news, weather and sports in the
news programming and then there's additional weather updates.
549 MS SPENRATH: Yes, that's correct.
550 MR. MORRIS: Is that how it works?
551 MR. JONES: The additional weather updates are more the
casual, you know, it's sunny and 25 today and here's Bruce Springsteen on T‑Rex.
552 MR. MORRIS: Right.
553 MR. JONES: What we're speaking of in the greater package
is the structured weather forecast that would come from within the news
package.
554 MR. MORRIS: Okay.
The second point. Someone
mentioned ‑‑ I forget who it was ‑‑ that 10
per cent of your music was going to be devoted to new music.
555 I just wondered
how you would define new music.
556 MR. JONES: For the 10 per cent it's more of a broad look
at what's gold, recurrent and
current. And songs generally come
out and have a life cycle to them that might be, you know, 16 or 20 weeks as a
song is released and gains popularity and over time moves to a recurrent
category where it generally spends, you know, a year or so and then moves to a
gold as it ages.
557 So, for the
purposes of what we're proposing here, that 10 per cent is a little bit more
vague. It's new songs that have been
released that haven't gotten old yet.
558 The four per cent
emerging artists would obviously fall under a different definition and would be
dedicated to Canadian music.
559 MR. MORRIS: So, new music would be broader than emerging
artists, it would be...?
560 MR. JONES: Well, new music could include a new song by
Tom Petty or a new song by Neil Young that wouldn't fall under any emerging
artist definition.
561 MR. MORRIS: Okay.
So, something like in the last 12 months or the last two years?
562 MR. JONES: Mm‑hmm.
I think the last six to 12 months is probably a fair definition of current
music.
563 MR. MORRIS: Okay.
Last thing. I just want to
confirm the letter from the district school board, you said you'd submit it by
the end of this week. Is Friday of this
week okay?
564 MS SPENRATH: Yes, Friday would be fine.
565 MR. MORRIS: Great.
Thank you.
566 THE
CHAIRPERSON: Okay. Mr. Steel, Mr. Murray, whoever, this is your
two minutes to tell us why we should select your application if the licence is
granted for Drumheller.
567 MR. MURRAY: Okay.
Thank you very much.
568 As we've said
several times, Drumheller is a very small community of only approximately
10,000 people, but it is a very important market for Newcap.
569 CKDQ‑AM has
served Drumheller and the surrounding area for nearly 50 years now and since
2002, when Newcap purchased the station, Newcap has dramatically improved the
service by eliminating network programming, we talked about a couple of times,
and adding a hundred per cent local programming and this is what T‑Rex is
going to be, a hundred per cent local programming as well.
570 But despite the
quality of the service, a single station cannot be all things all people. In order to be sure that we pick a musical
format that, you know, the people want in Drumheller, you know, we undertook
research, we were the only applicant that did that, and we chose a broad‑based
classic hits stations based on what people were listening to from out‑of‑market
tuning.
571 The presence of Q‑91,
CKDQ‑AM as a big sister station and the southern Alberta Radio Group as a
corporate resource will provide substantial benefits to T‑Rex 102.7,
including things like being a credible sales organization with existing
contacts in the community, being part of a provincial‑wide sales team
with the ability to aggregate audience, to attract national and regional
sales. We're doing that now in all of
our small market stations.
572 Association with
an existing Drumheller news team with a combined 27 years of experience in
Drumheller will greatly benefit T‑Rex.
573 Being part of a
news sharing service that provides ready access to regional and provincial
stories from all of our stations in Alberta through the KLZ system we have, all
the stories go up on a board and they can be readily accessed by the local
people and they take them and they can then tailor them to their market and re‑record
them and fire them back up.
574 We plan to add
three new people ‑‑ three new news people to the Drumheller
operation, resulting in a strong local newsroom that will strengthen the
regional service offered by Q‑91 and the local service of T‑Rex as
well.
575 We're going to
contribute $70,000 to CCD as we've outlined.
576 Finally, I should
note that our choice of frequency reaches the most people of the two chosen.
577 We'd like to thank
the Commissioners and staff for a thorough hearing, since we're fresh into it,
and the courtesy that you've extended to us today.
578 Thank you very
much.
579 THE
CHAIRPERSON: Thank you to you and your
panel.
580 And we're going to
take a 15‑minute break, so we'll be back at 11:25.
581 Thank you.
‑‑‑ Upon recessing
at 1110 / Suspension à 1110
‑‑‑ Upon resuming
at 1130 / Reprise à 1130
582 THE
SECRETARY: We will now proceed with Item
2, which is an application by Thomas Bolin, on behalf of a corporation to be
incorporated, for a licence to operate a low‑power English‑language
FM commercial radio programming undertaking in Drumheller.
583 The new station
would operate on Frequency 99.5 MHz, with an effective radiated power of 43.7
watts, non‑directional antenna, antenna height of 30 metres.
584 Appearing for the
applicant is Mr. Thomas Bolin.
585 Please introduce
your colleague. You will have 20 minutes
for your presentation.
*PRESENTATION / PRÉSENTATION
586 MR. BOLIN: Good morning.
I would like to say hello to the Commissioners, and I would like, first,
to thank you for allowing us to present our application at this hearing.
587 At this time I
would like to introduce our panel:
myself, Tom Bolin, and beside me, my wife and partner, Laurie Bolin.
588 We would like to
present to you what Valley FM is about and why we think our application is the
choice that the Commission should exclusively grant.
589 Being both born
and raised as residents of Drumheller, we feel that we know and understand the
wants and needs of our community. I
operate a construction company and a cabinet supply outlet, and have been in
business for myself for more than 25 years.
590 Laurie has been in
business as an administrator and a finance comptroller with the agricultural
dealership in Drumheller for the past seven years.
591 Our involvement in
the community includes, for myself, being a coach for girls' softball for five
years, and a minor hockey coach for 15 years.
592 We have raised
five children in the community of Drumheller, and have always been involved
with their extracurricular activities.
593 I am currently an
on‑ice official and a billet supporter for the Drumheller Dragons Junior
"A" Hockey Team.
594 I have in the past
been the President of the Drumheller Minor Hockey League, as well as Scout
leader and a member of the Knights of Columbus.
595 As for Laurie, she
will be in charge of our financial structure for Valley FM.
596 Her community
involvement includes Governor of girls' softball, President and Treasurer for
the Girl Guides of Canada, the Drumheller Group, and manager of teams in the
minor hockey system.
597 We participate
every year in local 4‑H calf shows and sales.
598 If you have been
to our town, you may know the landscape of Drumheller and our location in the
beautiful Red Deer River Valley. If not,
then, when you visit Drumheller, your trip will take you below the prairie
plateau onto the Red Deer River Valley floor.
599 As to our
location, this leaves us with the absence of quality commercial FM radio
signals, and the absence of contemporary music from Calgary or Red Deer, both
of which are over 130 kilometres away, and in no way contribute to the local
aspects of our town.
600 For a period of
time the residents of Drumheller could tune to out‑of‑market radio
and listen to AM radio stations from Calgary for their music of sixties to
today. There has been an absence of
contemporary music for a while, due to programming flips and the change from
the AM to the FM band.
601 We receive FM
radio signals from CKUA, as they have a transmitter in the Hand Hills, 40
kilometres from Drumheller. They are an
Alberta regional radio station and rarely have any local information about
Drumheller in their broadcasts.
602 Our application
started long before today. Over the past
four years we have asked and talked to many persons involved in broadcasting,
along with current Drumheller business owners.
We discussed the lack of local information and, at that time, local
content involving our community.
603 We found that most
Drumhellerites wanted a radio station that was Drumheller‑specific and
played a contemporary brand of music.
604 We decided that,
if we involved our community and provided our neighbours with the information
they need, along with the music they request, we would truly be a local radio
station.
605 There are many
businesses in the area that use radio for their promotions. We believe that if we provide an affordable
ad rate to non‑traditional radio users, we can get them on board to use
radio as their advertising tool.
606 Most business
persons informed us that they would support us if we were successful with our
application.
607 As we are not the
only applicants, and are not the seasoned broadcasters at this hearing, they,
too, must see a viable market in Drumheller after the Call for Applications.
608 Valley FM plans to
be the voice of Drumheller, as we will provide a total of 70 minutes of news
and sports, 27 minutes of stock or business reports, 9 minutes of school
reports, 18 minutes of special features, such as "Valley View" and
"Tonight in the Valley", 24 minutes of weather, 30 minutes of a
buy/trade/sell show, or "tradio", and a 5‑minute birthday show,
for an estimated total of 183 minutes per broadcast weekday, from 6 to 6, of
information programming, along with the numerous public service announcements
on the many events that take place throughout the area.
609 We will broadcast
24/7. Our broadcast day will begin with
a 12‑hour block with our in‑studio announcers. The remainder of the day will be computer
automation, with the exception of sports broadcasts or community events.
610 To start, between
6 and 9:30 a.m. there will be news and sports reports twice an hour, three
school reports, three business stock reports, and scheduled weather reports
every hour throughout the day. Also,
there will be a birthday phone‑in show.
611 Between 9:30 and
noon we will present a 30‑minute buy/trade/sell show. This will be an opportunity for the public to
be environmentally friendly by recycling their new and used items.
612 The next
information set will be in the noon hour, with three news/sports reports and a
business report.
613 At 4 p.m. we will
start Drumheller's afternoon drive with four news/sports updates and three
business reports.
614 We plan to use a
news service for international and national news, so we can concentrate on
providing our listeners with more local news coverage.
615 Valley FM has been
in touch with the Alberta Emergency Public Warning System, and will be
providing the Drumheller area with this service for weather advisories, flood
warnings, and, sadly, as we had a few months ago, the AMBER Alert.
616 In the area of
Canadian Talent Development and emerging artists, Drumheller has been blessed
with exceptional talent exposure, first with the success of Nickelback, which
grew up in our backyard, and which prompted many of the youth in the area to
create and form alternative rock and folk groups.
617 Drumheller has
been honoured to have a Top 10 and Top 2 finalist in "Canadian Idol"
with Jenn Beaupré and Jaydee Bixby.
618 Here in Drumheller,
the music scene is as diverse as anywhere, with numerous music events, like the
East Coulee Spring Festival, Wayne Fest, the Drumheller and District Music
Festival, the Rotary Club's "Beethoven and the Badlands", and the
Canada Day Festival, where bands like Downtyme and Blind Army have performed,
along with folk groups and artists like The TIPPLErs and Jenn Beaupré. All of these groups have recently released
CDs.
619 These venues are
the major musical attractions in our area.
620 Also, Drumheller is
dotted with clubs and community halls that also provide value with
entertainment.
621 Valley FM will
create a program called "Valley View", a one‑minute feature,
where we will showcase the cultural events happening in and around Drumheller,
focusing on people involved not exclusive to the music arts, but persons with
skills in art or a special talent, such as ceramics or gardening, or even
perhaps a Christmas light display. This
program will air 10 times a week.
622 "Tonight in
the Valley" will focus on evening performances, which will be at no charge
to the artist. This program will air
once every two hours over the broadcast day.
623 "Valley
Performances" will feature an interview of an emerging musical artist from
the valley or area, and a selection of their work, if available. This 15‑minute program will air twice
over the weekend.
624 Our choice of
musical selections will be the popular songs from the sixties to today.
625 We realize that
the Canadian content portion of the regulations of 35 percent is only the
minimum, and will be treated that way, as we plan to feature all‑Canadian
days or weekends.
626 Our contribution
to the Canadian Development Fund is the minimum, but we are also helping to
promote talent development at home, where we will see the results and have a
positive effect on local artists.
627 We, as the
concerned citizens of Drumheller, believe that an educated listener can only
have a positive effect on the community as a whole. We, as a Condition of Licence, will create
and broadcast a program called "You and the Law", where we will
solicit the local police and highway patrol to do vignettes on correct driving
laws and proper conduct as a citizen.
This program will be broadcast six times, randomly, throughout the day.
628 The workforce for
Valley FM will start with two full‑time on‑air personnel, a news
person, a traffic/reception/accounting person, and an account executive, for a
total of five full‑time employees.
629 Along with this
will be one part‑time employee for weekends, vacations or swing shifts.
630 We have negotiated
lease space with IP Plus for availability on their tower, and at their site
near Drumheller for our transmitter and antenna.
631 We are in the
process of finding affordable studio accommodations that will be the home of
Valley FM.
632 We asked the
community to contribute to the public process in our application, and they
responded overwhelmingly.
633 We must have more
than 100 letters of support, and many from persons who are and have been in the
radio industry.
634 This shows that
our neighbours believe that our application is the one the Commission should
approve.
635 Thank you for your
time, and if you have any questions, we will answer them now.
636 THE
CHAIRPERSON: Thank you, Mr. Bolin. Commissioner Cugini will lead the
questioning.
637 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: Thank you, Madam Chair.
638 Mr. Bolin and Ms
Bolin, good morning, and welcome to these proceedings. I have a few questions for you.
639 You haven't
appeared before us before, but you should know that I always like to start with
format questions, because that does form the basis of what the radio station
will sound like to the listeners, and, of course, it forms the basis of your
business plan.
640 In your
application you describe your format as rock, pop and dance, but I didn't hear
much today in your oral presentation elaborating further on that format. Is it still your intention to offer those
three genres of music?
641 MR. BOLIN: Drumheller is a small community, and like I
said before, we don't have access to a lot of music, due to the fact that a lot
of AM stations now have gone to talk or news, or whatever, and rock/pop/dance
would give us an opportunity to provide a bigger variety of music for the area.
642 We plan on having
a request line, and phone‑ins, so that people can request songs and we
can get a feel for the market and what we should be playing to make them happy
as listeners.
643 The rock/pop/dance
gives us a bigger area. We want to play
a variety of music, and we want to contribute to what the youth want to listen
to, as well. So, to get a wider scope,
or a bigger scope of the market, we would like to stay with that.
644 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: Do you intend on dedicating a
certain percentage of your playlist to rock, a certain percentage to pop, and
then a certain percentage to dance?
645 MR. BOLIN: I guess so.
We were planning on a Saturday night dance party in our programming, and
a Friday night bush party, which would be a little heavier rock, and during the
day just play the hits from the sixties to today, with a splattering of new
music, maybe the Top 20, once an hour, as we go through the broadcast day and
the weekend.
646 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: One of the difficulties we have
with this is, if you read what that category of music entails, what it
encompasses, according to our regs, it is this:
"Pop, rock and dance includes
music from the entire pop, rock and dance spectrum. This includes all types of rock music,
including soft rock, hard rock, classic rock, heavy metal, modern rock,
alternative rock, jazz rock, folk rock, and blues rock. It also includes pop, rock and roll, rhythm
and blues from the fifties and sixties, soul, dance, techno, rap, hip hop,
urban, and contemporary rhythm and blues.
This includes musical selections listed in charts compiled and published
by music trade publications." (As
read)
647 That is the
definition of the format you are proposing.
648 Are you intending
on including all of those formats?
649 Because in other
markets where we have heard applications ‑‑ and you heard
Newcap today, where they have honed it to just classic hits, which would come
from those sub‑categories of pop, rock and dance.
650 We are really
trying to get a handle on what the station will sound like.
651 I read that
verbatim to you to get a clearer sense from you as to whether or not you intend
on including all of that.
652 MR. BOLIN: Well, I guess we wouldn't include all of it.
653 The popular hits
from the sixties to today don't include a lot of heavy metal. They don't include, probably, any jazz or
anything like that.
654 The business
people we talked to and the people who supported us wanted a contemporary hit
station.
655 I was talking with
the CRTC, and they asked me that same question, because when I made my
application I had specified "rock/pop/dance", and I came back to
them ‑‑ they asked me that question, and I came back to them
and I told them that we were going to play hits from the sixties to today, and
on the website it came out as "rock/pop/dance".
656 So I was confused
at that point, but we are going to be playing contemporary hits from the
sixties to today, in the rock area.
657 We are going to
stay away from country and folk.
658 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: Would this be more properly
defined as a classic hits or a classic rock station, or an adult contemporary
station?
659 MR. BOLIN: I am having trouble with pigeonholing a
variety of music for 8,000 people in one town, when you are trying to provide
them with a service.
660 We are going to
get people who are going to want to hear The Beatles all day, or we are going
to get people who are going to want to hear Finger Eleven all day. And we are going to have a smattering,
probably, of requests for each one of those songs, and we will be playing each
of those genres.
661 So I guess we
would just say that it will be a classic hits station, or a classic hits format
that we will be going with.
662 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: At which point would you,
therefore, run the risk of being something for everyone and nothing for no one?
663 MR. BOLIN: At what point?
664 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: Yes.
665 Because one of the
things you say in your application ‑‑ and in your
supplementary brief, specifically, you say:
"Successful with listeners from 18 to 55."
666 That is a huge age
group to satisfy.
667 MR. BOLIN: Yes. A
55‑year‑old will be watching "Survivor" when the 18‑year‑old
is listening to the radio at night.
668 And an 18‑year‑old
should be in school, or at work, or whatever ‑‑ doing
something ‑‑ I am not saying 18 or 12 or 16 ‑‑
they would not be available when a 55‑year‑old would be listening
to the radio.
669 At different times
of the day there will be different demographics listening to the radio.
670 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: I will get into more specific
questions regarding advertising, but how will you describe that to your
potential advertisers, in terms of a demographic group that an advertiser would
want to target?
671 MR. BOLIN: Like I said, Drumheller is small. We are not a city like Calgary or Red Deer,
where you have a group of people that would categorize themselves with
one ‑‑
672 I don't know. It's tough to say.
673 You are going to
go to a community event, and there will be 80‑year‑olds there and
there will be 6‑year‑olds there, and they will all be at the
community event.
674 If you are going
to play music, you are going to play music that makes everybody a little bit
happy.
675 At what point
would I say that I am going to be a radio station for everybody or nobody? When the advertisers start telling me that it
is not working. They don't see any
results because nobody is listening to my station, because we are not playing
what their purchasers, or whoever, who are going to go to their stores and buy,
want.
676 If they are not
happy, we won't be happy.
677 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: One of the other things you say
in your application is that you will be taking a fresh look at the 12 to 18‑year‑old
group, and in previous hearings, such as these, we are constantly told that it
is the most difficult group to reach. It
is the group that is going to legal and illegal sites for their music. They are simply not listening to the radio.
678 So how are you
going to take a fresh look at this young group?
679 MR. BOLIN: We had planned on doing an evening ‑‑
although in our programming it says that our day stops at six o'clock, if we
can get some interest in that evening group, where you have kids and they are
texting and they are on the internet, they are going to want to hear about what
is happening in their community, too. If
we can get that group on the radio, to broadcast to that same group, you know,
as a high school student or a young person from the community, to provide them
with their type of music at that time, that is what we meant about what you had
mentioned.
680 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: So it would be through your
spoken word programming?
681 And, in
particular, through someone from that demographic group?
682 MR. BOLIN: Yes.
Yes, we would actually have an on‑air person, probably, doing a
program there.
683 That's where we
went with that. We want to be able to go
to the community and say: Look, we know
that you guys listen to this music, and if we are not playing this music, it is
not going to be hit music in the future.
We are not going to have classic hits in the future if we don't listen
to your music today.
684 That's where we
were going with that.
685 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: Okay. I know that you had some correspondence with
our staff regarding the number of hits that you would be playing, and I believe
that in your application you did say that you would commit to a maximum of 15
percent hits per broadcast week.
686 MR. BOLIN: I am not privy to that percentage.
687 Is that what you
have there?
688 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: That is what I have here in
terms of what you committed to in your application.
689 MR. BOLIN: Yes, we will go with that. We will play the 15 percent hits.
690 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: And you would accept that as a
Condition of Licence?
691 MR. BOLIN: Sure.
692 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: Our legal team may have more
questions on that, so be prepared.
693 In your
application you also mentioned a music survey and research that led you to
conclude that a pop/rock/dance format would serve Drumheller, and I looked
through your application and I didn't find any evidence of formal market
research.
694 You heard Newcap
today mention that they engaged Mark Kassof & Company to do their market
research. Could you elaborate a little
bit on the kind of research you did?
695 MR. BOLIN: My research was my personal research, by
talking to business people and the citizens of Drumheller, and mentioning that
I had made an application for an FM radio station. They said, "Yeah," and they said,
"What kind of music?" I told
them what kind of music we would have, and they said, "Well, could you
play this?" ‑‑ you know, a certain band, or something
like that ‑‑ and I said, "Yes, we will be playing hits
from the sixties to today."
696 And there was a
lot of positive feedback on it.
697 Actually, I never
got any negative feedback on any of this.
698 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: Can you tell us, approximately, how many people you spoke
with?
699 MR. BOLIN: Oh, probably 500 people.
700 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: And these were business people
in the Drumheller market?
701 MR. BOLIN: Business people, community leaders,
employees, friends, teammates ‑‑ everybody that I mentioned it
to, they all had some focus that this is what we need in Drumheller and it
would be good to have.
702 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: Of those 500 people, nobody
said, "Well, you know, I would rather listen to this other kind of radio
station"? They all agreed
with what you were proposing?
703 MR. BOLIN: No, one person didn't. She said, "Tom, you've got another pipe
dream." And she is a CKUA
supporter. And good on her.
704 There are lots of
people in Drumheller who do support CKUA because of the programming they
provide.
705 But I thought that
perhaps we could use a little rock and roll in Drumheller.
706 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: I will ask you the same question
that was asked of Newcap.
707 In this market
there is quite a bit of out‑of‑market tuning to the Calgary
stations. We can see that from the share
numbers.
708 What are you going
to provide to Drumheller listeners that they currently aren't getting from
listening to radio stations in Calgary?
709 In other words,
how are you going to make your radio station so attractive that the Drumheller
residents are going to change their listening habits and tune in to your radio
station?
710 MR. BOLIN: First of all, Drumheller receives no music
radio stations from Calgary on a constant level. You may get something ‑‑ it
depends on where the sun is, or whether it's a foggy day. I don't know what the heck it is, but the
only true station that we get in Drumheller is CKUA.
711 We do get AM
stations, and like I mentioned before, they have done flips from the AM to the
FM band, or they have gone all news, or whatever.
712 I think, just
turning on the transmitter in Drumheller and playing some rock and roll, people
are going to be switching over to our station.
713 There is
absolutely nothing there right now.
714 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: One of the most important
components of any business plan for a radio station, obviously, is what
percentage of the audience you think you will be able to attract.
715 Again, throughout
your application I didn't see any audience share numbers. Did you look at what percentage of the
audience you would be able to attract?
716 MR. BOLIN: I think in our application we mentioned that
50 percent of the audience would be listening to our station.
717 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: So you are projecting a 50
percent share.
718 MR. BOLIN: Yes.
719 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: Is that starting in Year 1?
720 MR. BOLIN: Yes.
721 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: And straight through to Year 7?
722 MR. BOLIN: Sure.
723 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: Do you see it increasing at all,
or do you see it staying steady at 50 percent?
724 MR. BOLIN: As long as we can keep the listener happy
with what we are providing, we will see an increase, or stay the same. If we can't, then there will probably be a
decrease.
725 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: Ad revenues, on the other hand,
are also projected based on share data.
How did you come up with your ad revenue projections?
726 MR. BOLIN: As a business owner, I have been approached
by CKDQ to advertise, and although my business is a construction business and a
cabinet business, I couldn't see the justification for the amount of money they
wanted for an ad on that station. So I
figured that if I could get an affordable ad rate, we could attract more people
to our station and get some non‑traditional advertisers on there.
727 I do think that
the advertising part of it was a little bit high for Drumheller, and that is
what prompted that.
728 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: So you have never advertised on
the AM radio station?
729 MR. BOLIN: No, I never have. I have used the newspaper.
730 Right now in
Drumheller ‑‑ in Drumheller, my phone rings every day, so
advertising would almost be moot for me.
It's not that I don't want people to know, or I could sponsor something,
but in my type of business a lot of it is ‑‑ you know, I did a
good job for somebody over there, "We will use him" type of thing.
731 I have been
approached by CKDQ, but, like I said before, their advertising rates were a
little bit too steep for me to actually justify ‑‑
732 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: I could have used you two years
ago when I renovated my kitchen.
‑‑‑ Laughter /
Rires
733 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: Your ad revenues appear to be
significantly lower than those projected by the other two applicants. And this, of course, demonstrates market
impact. In other words, how much of a
hit will the incumbent take if we license a new radio station ‑‑
one or two ‑‑ to serve Drumheller, and yours are, by far, the
lowest.
734 Are you being
overly cautious?
735 MR. BOLIN: Yes.
We had a business plan. We had
the opportunity to up our power during this application, but we thought that we
would stick with our business plan. We
want to start off small.
736 Drumheller is a
town that doesn't boom. Drumheller has
been here for a long time. It started in
the thirties as a mining community, and it kind of went downhill a little bit
during the fifties, and then it just kind of stayed the same.
737 It is a slow‑growing
town, so we decided to have our ad rate a little bit lower. I think we went with $20 an ad for two
minutes an hour, over the 12‑hour period that we are on in the
daytime. That is what we started with.
738 And we found that
we could probably sustain a radio station at that rate.
739 We don't have the
high transmitter costs, and we have a smaller staff than the other stations
would have.
740 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: One of the things we also need
to look at is a further breakdown of your ad revenue, and I am wondering if you
have had the opportunity to take a look at what percentage of your total
advertising will come from new advertisers, that is, people like yourselves,
who haven't used radio as a medium before, what percentage will come from
increased budgets of existing advertisers, how much will come from the
incumbent radio station, and how much will come from other media, that is,
print or ‑‑
741 Do you have that
breakdown?
742 MR. BOLIN: No. We
are a brand new business idea. We would
almost have to go into their books to know what the heck is going on here
before we would have that.
743 We just kind of
figured that we could sell this. I'm
sorry to say that, but we have our heart and soul in this, too.
744 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: We find that most people in radio
do.
745 MR. BOLIN: Yes.
746 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: Okay. I am going to move on to your spoken word
programming. You did give us a bit more
detail today, but, generally, you say in your application that you will be 100
percent local, and that is equal to 126 hours a week. But at another point you say that you will be
local for 60 hours a week.
747 Can you confirm to
me which it is? Is it 126, or is it
anything less than 126?
748 MR. BOLIN: Our on‑air would be 60 hours a week,
and although we are in the community, we would be there ‑‑ we
are not networked, we wouldn't be taken into syndication programming at this
point.
749 I guess we would
say that it would be 60 hours.
750 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: And the rest would be voice
tracked?
751 MR. BOLIN: Not voice tracked, automation or ‑‑
752 We haven't talked
about voice track.
753 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: Are you planning on doing any
voice track programming?
754 MR. BOLIN: Yes, we could probably do some, but I am not
a great fan of voice track. It is kind
of ‑‑
755 I would rather
have somebody in the studio, myself.
756 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: So if you are live for 60 hours,
what are you doing for the other 66?
757 MR. BOLIN: Automation.
It wouldn't be voice track, it would be automation. It would be computer automation, with our
station breaks and our PSAs, and advertising that would be automated.
758 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: All right. Give me a sense of what you mean by computer
automated.
759 Is your radio
station running on a wheel at this point, the 60 hours are then repeated?
760 MR. BOLIN: No.
No, if we break it down to one day ‑‑
761 Let's do one day.
762 From six in the
morning until six at night ‑‑
763 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: Right.
764 MR. BOLIN: ‑‑
we will have two announcers in there, a news guy, and then at six at night we
turn on the computer and we have the computer play the music, and we have our
ads injected, and we have our automated news service, if there is one.
765 We plan on doing
that, and let it just operate by itself, so we can take a day off, or take the
evening off.
766 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: Would anybody be available
during those hours should there be an emergency, should there be a requirement
for an emergency alert to be broadcast?
767 MR. BOLIN: The Alberta Emergency Alert Service actually
overrides your radio station, and they go on‑air when they want to. They take over your programming.
768 We could probably
be attached to something that ‑‑ obviously, we are going to be
listening to our radio station and we will know that.
769 Drumheller is a
small community. We have "rush
minute", we don't have "rush hour", and it wouldn't be hard to
get to the studio at all.
770 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: Okay. Thank you.
771 In terms of the
specifics of your spoken word programming ‑‑ and I am going to
refer to your oral presentation that you just delivered to us ‑‑
you say "for an estimated total of 183 minutes per broadcast weekday"
would be total spoken word. So that is
two hours and 23 minutes per day of spoken word. Correct?
772 MR. BOLIN: Correct.
773 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: For a total of 21 hours and 35
minutes weekly of spoken word?
774 Hopefully my
colleagues and the accountants are impressed by that quick calculation.
‑‑‑ Laughter /
Rires
775 MR. BOLIN: If that is what it calculates out to ‑‑
776 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: Okay. So 21 hours and 35 minutes weekly of spoken
word.
777 Of that, you say
that 70 minutes a day will be news and sports.
778 MR. BOLIN: Yes.
779 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: Of that 70 minutes a day, how
much is strictly news?
780 MR. BOLIN: We plan on using a news service. So there would be a three‑minute
national news feed, and a two‑minute local news broadcast, and then ‑‑
781 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: And who would do that two
minutes of local news?
782 MR. BOLIN: Our news person.
783 We also will have
a sports ‑‑ about a three‑minute sports injection there.
784 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: I just want to know the news
component.
785 This three minutes
of news service, would that be a national news service that you would be
subscribing to?
786 MR. BOLIN: Yes, it would be Broadcast News.
787 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: Broadcast News. Okay.
Thank you.
788 MR. BOLIN: I will use them as an example. I have been talking to them. I am not aware of anybody else who provides
that service.
789 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: The other elements of your
spoken word programming ‑‑ for example, the stock and business
reports and the school reports, as well as "Valley View" and
"Tonight in the Valley" ‑‑ those would all be
produced by your on‑air personalities?
790 MR. BOLIN: Yes.
791 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: Which leads me to the question
of staffing, because that is commendable.
It is a high level of spoken word programming, and that is a lot of work
for two full‑time on‑air personnel and a news person.
792 How hard are you
going to work these people to be able to produce that level of spoken word
programming?
793 MR. BOLIN: We also will have an account executive there
who will be out in the community talking to people.
794 Our policy is
going to be that you will have to have a recording device with you whenever you
leave the studio, because we are sound, we are not pictures, we are not
anything else.
795 So any information
you can get ‑‑ and if we have to, we will go out and find
these people.
796 I know a lot of
people that play the piano and the guitars in the bands, and stuff like that,
and I could probably provide a year's supply of programming myself.
797 Not mentioned in
our staff was myself, as general manager.
These were only the hired employees.
So that would be another employee, or another person at the station.
798 And we want to
encourage internship or ‑‑ whatever it takes, because radio
needs more new people and new sounds, and this would be an opportunity for
someone to go out and do some of this stuff.
799 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: So you will be offering
internship opportunities ‑‑
800 MR. BOLIN: Sure, yes.
801 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: ‑‑ and opportunities to volunteers, for example?
802 MR. BOLIN: Yes.
803 We want to be
truly local.
804 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: Okay. I am going to move on to your Canadian
Content Development commitments.
805 In your
application, again, you cite at one point $1,500 per year, and at another point
you say $1,900 per year for CCD. Can you
confirm to us which of those two figures is your CCD commitment?
806 MR. BOLIN: Could I have a moment?
807 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: Absolutely.
‑‑‑ Pause
808 MR. BOLIN: I am having trouble finding that.
809 I know that we
committed $500 for a scholarship for the high school and ‑‑
810 I can't figure out
what ‑‑
811 Could you refresh
my memory?
812 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: I do have in your financial
projections for Canadian Talent Development ‑‑ I have a figure
of $1,500. So perhaps just the $1,900
was an error in your application, and we will take $1,500 as your yearly
commitment to CCD?
813 MR. BOLIN: Yes.
There was a minimum in there, but we ‑‑
814 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: Are you referring to the basic
contribution? Is that perhaps ‑‑
815 MR. BOLIN: Wasn't the basic contribution $400?
816 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: It is $500.
817 MR. BOLIN: It is $500?
818 Okay, it is $500.
819 We were going to
allow another $500 to ‑‑
820 I think it is only
$1,500, yes, because we are going to give another $500 to the high school, as a
scholarship, and we are going to award another $500 to the music festivals, I'm
sure.
821 I hate to be
uninformed about that. I thought I knew
about that one, but ‑‑
822 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: That's okay. It's a lot of information.
823 So, therefore,
your over‑and‑above contribution is $1,000 a year.
824 MR. BOLIN: Yes.
825 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: And then, if we add that to your
basic contribution of $500, that brings us to the total of $1,500 per year of
CCD.
826 MR. BOLIN: Yes.
827 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: One of the things that we
introduced in the Commercial Radio Policy was that, of the basic contribution
of $500, 60 percent would go to FACTOR or Musique Action.
828 Do you agree with
that, and will you accept that as a Condition of Licence?
829 MR. BOLIN: Sure.
830 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: Of the over‑and‑above,
therefore, of the $1,000, 20 percent of that would go to FACTOR or Musique
Action.
831 Is that acceptable
to you as a Condition of Licence?
832 MR. BOLIN: So of the $1,000 ‑‑ that
would be $1,200?
833 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: Twenty percent of the $1,000.
834 MR. BOLIN: So that would only be $800 allotted to the
scholarship and the award?
835 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: And the music festival, yes.
836 MR. BOLIN: That is almost like stealing away from those guys,
isn't it?
837 I am going to say
no. I would rather give those guys in
Drumheller the money than to have it leave the community.
838 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: So should we, then ‑‑
839 Okay, we are going
to have to work this one out.
840 With $500 for the
scholarship ‑‑
841 MR. BOLIN: Or we will donate the $1,200 and make up the
difference.
842 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: Donate the $1,200 to...?
843 MR. BOLIN: To the $1,000 we will add another $200, just
to make up the difference. It will be
easy math then. We don't mind.
844 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: Okay. Thank you.
Easy math is always a good thing.
845 MR. BOLIN: Yeah, that's good.
846 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: Thank you for that.
847 In terms of the
scholarship, have you contacted any educational institutions in the Drumheller
market to determine which offer programs that would make this an eligible CCD
contribution?
848 MR. BOLIN: Not formally.
I have talked to the principals of both schools.
849 We now have two
high schools, one a Catholic high school, and the Golden Hills School Division
has their school. I haven't talked to
either one of the principals.
850 This was a plan
that we had, and I am sure they wouldn't turn it down, if one of their students
was registered in the broadcast industry or music, to further their career in
university, or wherever.
851 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: And both of these high schools
offer music programs?
852 MR. BOLIN: Yes.
853 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: The music festival ‑‑
is this a contribution that you would be making to a music festival that
currently exists in Drumheller?
854 MR. BOLIN: The music festival does currently exist. It has been running for about 80 years, I
think.
855 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: And what is the nature of that
music festival?
856 MR. BOLIN: It is a showcase of the talent of Drumheller,
and persons of the valley. They have the
opportunity to perform in their special field, whether it be spoken word or
music.
857 And they are
adjudicated, and they are graded, and then the top ‑‑
858 The adjudicators
pick an evening performance, and then those people go on to the Alberta Music
Festival, and from there they ‑‑
859 It is an
opportunity for talent to be recognized in Drumheller.
860 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: So this would be a contribution
to that festival, but not necessarily specifically to a participant in the
festival.
861 MR. BOLIN: We could actually pick somebody in the
festival, in a certain category that we wanted the contribution awarded to,
like a finalist in percussion, or a finalist in piano, or a finalist in spoken
word or poetry. We could pick them, and
they actually receive monetary awards besides trophies and other gifts.
862 We would like to
help sponsor that program. It is a
community ‑‑ a vibrant community project in Drumheller.
863 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: I have one final question, Mr.
Bolin, and it's a bit of a tough question, I will grant you that.
864 My colleagues may
have others, and legal staff may have other questions, as well.
865 I hear you. Drumheller is a small community of 8,000 people. You are a well‑respected businessman in
the community. There is a very strong
incumbent, Newcap, which is serving the radio market currently. Newcap is an applicant in these proceedings. Golden West is another applicant, another
well‑heeled broadcaster, with loads of experience. Why should we trust you to run a radio
station in Drumheller?
866 MR. BOLIN: Because I live here. I live in this community and I love the
community, and I think that someone who has a finger on the pulse of the community
would be able to contribute more.
867 We are looking
beyond the monetary gains of making a dollar in the advertising industry.
868 Our whole idea was
to provide Drumheller with an alternative to the AM station we have now.
869 Our idea was to
provide more information. Our idea was
to get the community more involved with itself.
870 Many things happen
in our community, and we have to depend on the newspaper, which comes out once
a week, to find out what is going on, or what had gone on, or who won an award,
because our local station is not providing that information.
871 That is why I
think I should be the applicant that you guys select.
872 COMMISSIONER
CUGINI: Thank you very much, Mr. Bolin,
and Ms Bolin.
873 Thank you, Madam
Chair.
874 THE CHAIRPERSON: Commissioner Patrone?
875 COMMISSIONER
PATRONE: How are you both doing today?
876 MR. BOLIN: Not bad, and you?
877 COMMISSIONER
PATRONE: I'm fine, thank you.
878 I just want to ask
a couple of quick questions.
879 You said, Mr.
Bolin, that you are involved with the Drumheller Dragons.
880 Is that correct?
881 MR. BOLIN: Yes, I am a billet supporter.
882 I am not an on‑ice
official for the juniors, I am too old for that. They get the young guys to do that.
883 But I do minor
hockey.
884 COMMISSIONER
PATRONE: Do you have any plans for live
coverage of the games, or playing back the games?
885 MR. BOLIN: Yes.
Actually, there is a young lad in Drumheller, his name is Jason Blanke,
and he is the voice of the Dragons. He
does the arena broadcasting, or the arena announcing.
886 He travels with
the team and broadcasts the games on the internet back to Drumheller or ‑‑
well, across the world, I guess.
887 So we can actually
find out what is going on with our hockey team.
888 Also, part of the
prerequisite to belong to the Alberta Junior Hockey League is to have a
broadcast of your game.
889 They do both the
home and the away games.
890 We have been
talking to Jason, and we plan on handling the Junior "A" Hockey
Team. I think that Drumheller is the
only town that has a Junior "A" Hockey Team in Alberta that doesn't
have the games broadcast.
891 We have talked to
the incumbent, CKDQ, and they said it was just too cost prohibitive for them to
have somebody go out and do that, but I think we could do that just fine.
892 COMMISSIONER
PATRONE: You spoke about doing
recordings of local bands, if I heard you correctly ‑‑ going
out and actually recording shows?
893 Is that what you
are planning on doing? And, if so, are
you planning on airing those shows in their entirety?
894 MR. BOLIN: Well, I don't know, you have to edit a little
bit.
895 The East Coulee
Spring Festival is a prime example. It
is a showcase for the community to fundraise for the community.
896 If you have ever
been to Drumheller, and if you have any geographics of Drumheller ‑‑
I mean how it is laid out ‑‑ it is a long town now. It stretches right down the valley
about ‑‑ I don't know ‑‑ 10 or 12 kilometres,
whatever it is. East Coulee was one
community at one time. It was a town by
itself, and it has evolved into Drumheller.
897 They have a spring
festival, and if we go out and record this spring festival, we plan on
broadcasting parts of it back to the public just to promote that program so we
can say this is the kind of music you are going to be able to hear out there
and just help the community out because that's ‑‑ you know,
that's what I think a radio station is all about. We should go out there and just do this.
898 COMMISSIONER
PATRONE: What about school reports? You said you are going to have nine minutes?
899 MR. BOLIN: Yes.
900 COMMISSIONER
PATRONE: What exactly is a school
report?
901 MR. BOLIN: Yes, that's a good question.
‑‑‑ Laughter /
Rires
902 MR. BOLIN: A school report would be someone from the
school whether it be a principal, a teacher, a student, telling us what's going
to happen after school for the day, what's happening in their sporting events,
whether it's pajama day or crazy hair day or whatever; just get the kids
involved in the radio station and in the broadcasting part of it so we
can ‑‑ I think if we get the kids involved we will get the
adults listening because their kids are on the radio and we are going to be
able to sell advertising that way.
903 COMMISSIONER
PATRONE: You spoke about All Canadian
Days.
904 MR. BOLIN: Yes.
905 COMMISSIONER
PATRONE: I imagine July 1st would be a
pretty good candidate for that.
906 MR. BOLIN: Yes, that's a good one.
907 COMMISSIONER
PATRONE: Just curious, how many of these
days do you plan on having and is this going to be like a regular segment on
your station?
908 MR. BOLIN: If the Commission wants it a condition of
licence I could schedule probably one a month if you wanted but probably that
might be a little too much.
909 We would like to
do some different things like all Canadian, like July 1st or May long weekend
or, I don't know, sometime in December you know or January, maybe even January
1st, the all Canadian or whatever.
910 Yes, we do plan
on doing that because I do believe ‑‑ I'm a very patriotic
guy. I have got a flag in my yard. You know, I believe in what we are doing over
in Afghanistan. I believe it in all and
I do believe that being a Canadian and promoting our talent here in Canada is
number one.
911 COMMISSIONER
PATRONE: I want to thank you both for
coming here today.
912 Commissioner ‑‑
thank you, Madam Chair.
913 THE
CHAIRPERSON: Commissioner Molnar.
914 COMMISSIONER
MOLNAR: Thank you and welcome this
morning.
915 MR. BOLIN: Thank you.
916 COMMISSIONER
MOLNAR: I just have a couple of questions.
917 I want to first
ask about the financial forecast. I
realize that you have put forward a business plan that is significantly
different than the other applicants before us here today. I would say a scaled‑down version, you
know?
918 MR. BOLIN: Yes.
919 COMMISSIONER
MOLNAR: But you project that you will be
PBIT‑positive in year one and each year thereafter. And if we look, for example, at the incumbent
and their forecast, the application they put forward, they would project that
they will incur losses in the first four years of the new radio station. That's very significant to carry losses for
any period of time.
920 And I just
wondered about the financial capacity that you might have should the financials
not be as positive as you project.
921 MR. BOLIN: Well, first of all, we don't plan on
failing. I understand ‑‑
922 COMMISSIONER
MOLNAR: And fair enough. I don't think they would plan on failing
either when they are carrying those losses towards ‑‑
923 MR. BOLIN: Yes.
924 COMMISSIONER MOLNAR:
‑‑ you know, achieving financial success.
925 MR. BOLIN: To carry the downfall in case there isn't the
projected monies you know, we haven't even ‑‑ we didn't think
about that part other than, you know, dipping into some savings or something
like that to get it going.
926 COMMISSIONER
MOLNAR: M'hm.
927 MR. BOLIN: Or maybe scale back a bit if it's a
possibility of employees or something like that. But I don't want to do that. Yes, it would probably have to be financial.
928 We also plan on
selling shares in our company. So we
probably could have some monies generated through that. I know nobody wants to invest in a company
that's going downhill, by no means, but if we can get online with these people
with investors prior to any downturn, but I really can't see that happening
right now.
929 COMMISSIONER
MOLNAR: Right, and please, I'm not
suggesting that you would see a downturn, more of a ramp up.
930 MR. BOLIN: Yes.
931 COMMISSIONER
MOLNAR: You know which is what we see
traditionally within the business cases of new stations.
932 MR. BOLIN: Yes.
933 COMMISSIONER
MOLNAR: Is that you would see losses in
the first years as you build your audience share, as you recover some of the
capital costs related to putting forward ‑‑ or putting
together a new station. You know there
is that front end load cost, if you will, and I think ‑‑ you
know, you say a suggestion might be to decrease staff. Of course, with five staff it's pretty
difficult to think that's ‑‑
934 MR. BOLIN: Yes, yes.
935 COMMISSIONER
MOLNAR: ‑‑ a possibility.
So I think it is a true potential that that might have to be carried by
the principal investors.
936 MR. BOLIN: Yes.
937 COMMISSIONER
MOLNAR: That sort of loss, is that
something that ‑‑
938 MR. BOLIN: Yes, that's what we would plan then.
939 COMMISSIONER
MOLNAR: Okay.
940 Could I just ask a
little bit about the experience that would be available to run the radio
station? Obviously, you are an
experienced business man. You are
talking about bringing in five resources, two on air people; your account
executive.
941 Do you see being
able to acquire people with radio experience as part of that group of five who
would understand some of the, you know, regulatory commitments you need to make
and so on to ensure that you remain compliant and relevant to your market?
942 MR. BOLIN: Yes, we had decided that we would have to
hire someone who has gone to school in the broadcast industry to get us up and
online.
943 Part of it was
trying to be local and first of all have someone from the community apply for
the jobs and take the jobs that are in there.
We do ‑‑ yes, like we said, we would like to hire
somebody that has gone to broadcast school so they can help us get up and
going.
944 We are small. We are going to be small so we will be like
an entry‑level broadcaster. We are
not going to be, you know, full fledged.
The main thing ‑‑ I don't know. That's probably it.
945 COMMISSIONER
MOLNAR: Okay.
946 I'm going to move
on from that, and I asked Newcap who was here before you a couple of questions
that I would like to ask you as well; one related to cultural diversity.
947 And I realize you
are small. You are going to be on the
air just 60 hours but do you see somehow being able to reflect within your
programming schedule the cultural makeup of your marketplace?
948 MR. BOLIN: Our marketplace is ‑‑ you
know, I don't want to say it but we are very isolated in Drumheller. We don't have First Nations lands near
us. We don't have an influx of ethnic
people in Drumheller. It grew up as a
European farming community. I hate to
say it, but most of the people are white Anglo‑Saxons.
949 Our biggest
diversity there would be a religious one which would be the farming communities
of the Hudderites. Drumheller does not
have a big native population.
950 Our biggest ‑‑
probably the closest thing to a native population would be we do have a
penitentiary and 50 percent of the population in that penitentiary are
native. And we did consider having
native broadcasting from a broadcaster in northern Alberta ‑‑
provide us with a couple of hours a week.
So we could have some native broadcasting for those guys there but they
don't ‑‑ they can't get out and buy anything so all it
would ‑‑ that would be just a public service to them.
951 The diversity in
our town, there is really no hatred or anything. I'm not saying it's not there but it's not
visible. We accept everyone in our
community. We have ‑‑
you know, like visible minorities are just us.
They are just regular folk that is us.
So they are going to listen to the same type of music as us, I hope,
unless they have a specific song they want to hear from wherever they are from,
you know, or whatever their origin is.
952 I'm just saying
that our selection of music and our programming it's going to be for
Drumheller. Don't think that I don't see
anything out there, you know, for different ethnic groups and stuff like that
but it's just not there in Drumheller, you know.
953 COMMISSIONER
MOLNAR: Okay, thank you.
954 My last question
relates to use of the internet or other sources of new media to support your
radio station. Would you see ‑‑
would you have plans to use new distribution platforms such as the internet to
put forward a website that would support and promote your station?
955 MR. BOLIN: Yes.
We have a large community of first of all, Junior A hockey players that
come from all over Alberta and Canada to play.
And their parents aren't there and they would like to hear their hockey
players play the game. If we
broadcast ‑‑ our broadcast day if we put it on the internet,
then they have a chance to hear that.
956 We also have a
large community of international students in Drumheller that attend our high
school and they come from Mexico, China, France, all over the world they come
to Drumheller. This would be also an
opportunity for their parents to see what is going on in the community that
they ‑‑ where they live.
957 So we do plan on
using the internet and we would like to use all the technologies available
other than podcasting or cell phones right now.
We don't want to get too cost‑prohibitive.
958 The internet, if
we go on streaming on the internet it's going to cost us for as many people go
on. We want to put a quality product on
there. We would sell advertising on that
website as long as the CRTC doesn't regulate too much of that. I know that they want to change some of the
regulations in that area and we would be happy with anything they had.
959 COMMISSIONER
MOLNAR: Okay, just one quick follow up.
960 Did you
incorporate the costs of creating that website and any associated costs of
streaming into your financial forecasts?
961 MR. BOLIN: Yes.
962 COMMISSIONER
MOLNAR: Yes?
963 MR. BOLIN: We presently own valleyfm.ca and we have used
this website to solicit support for our application here today. And we plan on using that site to stream our
broadcast day.
964 COMMISSIONER
MOLNAR: Okay. Thank you very much. Those are my questions.
965 MR. BOLIN: Thank you.
966 THE
CHAIRPERSON: Mr. Bolin, I have a few
questions.
967 I am just
wondering, first of all, I would just like to better understand, after six
o'clock in the evening you say the programming is going to be played using a
computer? Can you just tell me how that
would be programmed? I don't quite
understand that.
968 MR. BOLIN: Pardon me?
969 THE
CHAIRPERSON: I don't quite understand
that. Can you tell me how that will be
programmed?
970 MR. BOLIN: Well, during the broadcast day we use
computers to play music and ads and everything.
So what you can do now is turn on a computer and it can play song after
song.
971 THE
CHAIRPERSON: Yes.
972 MR. BOLIN: I know we are not going to be a jukebox but,
you know, we can fill up the rest of the broadcast day. You do have a choice, I suppose, of shutting
off your transmitter or to turn on a computer and have people listen.